Finding the Best Antique Appraisers Near You: A Complete Guide

Determining the value of antiques can be challenging without professional expertise. Whether you’ve inherited family heirlooms, discovered items in your attic, or are looking to sell part of your collection, finding a qualified antique appraiser in your area is crucial for obtaining accurate valuations. This comprehensive guide will help you locate, evaluate, and work with the best antique appraisers near you.

Table of Contents

1. Why You Need a Professional Antique Appraiser
2. How to Find Antique Appraisers in Your Area
3. Evaluating Appraiser Credentials
4. Understanding Appraisal Costs
5. What to Expect During an Appraisal
6. Types of Antique Appraisals
7. Online vs. In-Person Appraisals
8. Popular Appraisal Services
9. Preparing for Your Appraisal
10. After the Appraisal

Professional antique appraisers bring specialized knowledge, experience, and objectivity to the valuation process that casual collectors and even seasoned enthusiasts typically lack. Their expertise can significantly impact your understanding of an item’s worth and its potential in the marketplace.

Benefits of Professional Antique Appraisals

• Accurate Valuation: Professionals apply standardized methodologies to determine fair market value
• Insurance Documentation: Proper appraisals provide essential documentation for insuring valuable items
• Estate Planning: Accurate valuations help with fair distribution of assets and tax planning
• Authentication: Experts can identify reproductions, fakes, or altered items
• Historical Context: Appraisers provide insights into your item’s historical significance and provenance
• Market Knowledge: Professionals understand current market trends and demand for specific items

Finding a reputable antique appraiser doesn’t have to be difficult. Here are several effective methods to locate professional appraisers in your community:

1. Professional Directories and Organizations

Start by consulting directories from professional appraisal associations. These organizations maintain lists of certified members who adhere to specific ethical standards and continuing education requirements:

• International Society of Appraisers (ISA)
• American Society of Appraisers (ASA)
• Appraisers Association of America (AAA)

These organizations typically allow you to search for appraisers by location and specialty.

2. Local Antique Shops and Auction Houses

Established antique dealers and auction houses either employ appraisers or can recommend trusted professionals:

• Visit antique stores in your area and ask for recommendations
• Contact local auction houses like Selkirk Auctioneers & Appraisers for referrals
• Attend antique shows where you can meet dealers and appraisers

3. Online Search and Review Platforms

Online platforms can help you find and evaluate local appraisers:

• Yelp’s antique appraisal sections list businesses by location with customer reviews
• Better Business Bureau’s directory, like this one for Saint Louis
• Google Maps searches for “antique appraisers near me”
• Angie’s List (now Angi) features customer-reviewed appraisers

4. Museum Connections

Local museums often maintain relationships with appraisers or may have staff who perform appraisals:

• Contact the curator at your local history or art museum
• Ask about appraisal events or recommendations for private appraisers
• Inquire about “appraisal day” events where multiple appraisers gather

5. Estate Sale Companies

Companies that manage estate sales typically work with appraisers:

• Research estate sale businesses in your area
• Contact companies like Brad Peele’s Estate Sales and Appraisals for information

Searchable database of certified appraisers specializing in antiques and various collectibles.

Find ASA-accredited appraisers near you with advanced search filters by location and specialty.

Database of AAA-certified appraisers with specialized expertise in various antique categories.

Regional directories of antique appraisers with contact information and specialties.

Not all antique appraisers have the same level of expertise or professional standards. Here’s how to evaluate potential appraisers:

Professional Certifications

Look for appraisers with recognized credentials:

• ISA Member (International Society of Appraisers): Requires rigorous coursework and testing
• ASA (American Society of Appraisers): Offers accreditation in specific disciplines
• AAA (Appraisers Association of America): Focuses on fine and decorative arts
• USPAP Compliance: Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice certification is essential for legal and tax purposes

Specialization Areas

Antiques cover a vast range of categories. The best appraisers specialize in specific areas:

• Furniture (period-specific: Victorian, Mid-Century, etc.)
• Fine art and paintings
• Silver and metalwork
• Ceramics and porcelain
• Textiles and rugs
• Clocks and watches
• Jewelry and gemstones
• Militaria and historical items

Experience and Education

Evaluate the appraiser’s background:

• Years of experience in the field
• Formal education in art history, decorative arts, or related fields
• Continuing education (the antiques market constantly evolves)
• Museum or auction house experience
• Publishing history or academic contributions

Client References

Don’t hesitate to:

• Ask for client references
• Read online reviews from multiple sources
• Request samples of previous appraisal reports (with confidential information redacted)

Appraisal costs vary widely depending on several factors, including the appraiser’s expertise, reputation, location, and the type of appraisal needed.

Typical Fee Structures

Professional appraisers typically charge using one of these methods:

• Hourly rate: Common for most appraisals, typically ranging from $100-$300 per hour
• Flat fee per item: Used for single item appraisals, ranging from $250-$350 for the first item
• Minimum fee: Many appraisers set a minimum engagement fee regardless of time spent
• Daily rate: For large collections or estates, often $800-$1,200 per day
• Percentage-based: Less common and generally considered unethical by professional organizations

According to WorthWise Appraisers, “Typically, formal appraisals for a single item start at about $250 to $350. Additional items will typically add incremental costs of between $25 and $100 per item.”

Cost Factors

Several variables influence the final cost:

• Complexity: Unusual, rare, or highly specialized items require more research
• Documentation needed: Formal written reports cost more than verbal consultations
• Purpose: Insurance appraisals require more detailed documentation than casual valuations
• Location: In-home visits like those offered by Dr. Lori typically come with premium pricing
• Number of items: Volume discounts may apply for multiple pieces
• Travel expenses: If the appraiser must travel to your location
• Turnaround time: Rush appraisals often incur additional fees

Free or Low-Cost Options

While professional appraisals have their costs, some alternatives can provide preliminary guidance:

• Antique shows with appraisal booths: Often charge $5-20 per item for brief consultations
• Museum-sponsored appraisal days: Similar to the format of TV shows like Antiques Roadshow
• Auction house evaluations: Some offer free evaluations hoping you’ll consign items
• Antique dealer opinions: May offer free assessments, but beware of conflicts of interest
• Online appraisal platforms: Typically charge $10-30 per item for digital appraisals

The appraisal process follows a fairly standardized approach, whether conducted in your home, at an appraiser’s office, or at an appraisal event.

Initial Consultation

Before the formal appraisal begins:

1. Discuss purpose: Clarify why you need the appraisal (insurance, sale, estate planning)
2. Review items: Provide preliminary information about what you’re having appraised
3. Establish scope: Determine whether you need verbal consultation or written documentation
4. Agree on fees: Get a clear understanding of costs and payment methods
5. Schedule the appraisal: Set a date, time, and location

The Appraisal Process

During the actual appraisal:

1. Physical examination: The appraiser will carefully inspect each item
2. Documentation: Photos will be taken from multiple angles
3. Measurements: Precise dimensions will be recorded
4. Markings and signatures: The appraiser will examine maker’s marks, signatures, or stamps
5. Condition assessment: Damage, repairs, and overall condition will be noted
6. Questions about provenance: You’ll be asked about the item’s history and documentation
7. Initial observations: The appraiser may share preliminary thoughts

Research Phase

After examining your items, the appraiser will:

1. Conduct comparable sales research: Examine similar items that have recently sold
2. Consult reference materials: Use specialized resources and databases
3. Verify authenticity: Research to confirm or question the item’s attribution
4. Consider market factors: Assess current demand and market trends
5. Draft the appraisal report: Compile findings into formal documentation

Final Delivery

The appraisal concludes with:

1. Written report delivery: You’ll receive the formal appraisal document
2. Review of findings: The appraiser will explain their conclusions
3. Value discussion: Clear explanation of how values were determined
4. Recommendations: Potential next steps based on the appraisal results
5. Questions and clarifications: Opportunity to address any concerns

Contact the appraiser, discuss your needs, agree on fees, and schedule the appraisal appointment.

Appraiser examines items, takes photographs, measures dimensions, and assesses condition.

Appraiser researches comparable sales, verifies authenticity, and evaluates current market demand.

Formal appraisal report is created with detailed descriptions, photographs, and valuations.

Appraiser delivers the report, explains findings, and answers any questions about the valuation.

Appraisals serve various purposes, and the type you need will determine the approach, documentation, and sometimes even the appraiser you should select.

Purpose-Based Appraisals

Different purposes require specific approaches:

Insurance Appraisals

• Purpose: Document value for insurance coverage
• Valuation Standard: Replacement value (cost to replace with similar item)
• Detail Level: Highly detailed with extensive documentation
• Updates Required: Typically every 3-5 years as markets change

Estate Appraisals

• Purpose: Establish values for estate tax or division of assets
• Valuation Standard: Fair market value (likely sale price in appropriate market)
• Detail Level: Comprehensive with IRS-compliant methodology
• Legal Requirements: Must meet specific IRS guidelines and timing requirements

Donation Appraisals

• Purpose: Establish value for charitable donation tax deduction
• Valuation Standard: Fair market value
• Detail Level: Must meet IRS requirements, especially for items valued over $5,000
• Appraiser Requirements: IRS has specific qualifications for appraisers

Resale Appraisals

• Purpose: Determine potential selling price
• Valuation Standard: Market value or liquidation value
• Detail Level: Often less formal with market analysis
• Considerations: Different markets (auction, retail, wholesale) yield different values

Format-Based Appraisals

Appraisals also vary by documentation level:

Verbal Consultations

• Quick assessments with verbal value ranges
• No formal documentation
• Lower cost but limited usefulness for official purposes

Written Appraisals

• Formal documents with detailed descriptions and values
• Photos and condition reports included
• Meets requirements for legal, tax, and insurance purposes

Identification and Authentication Services

• Focus on confirming what an item is rather than its value
• Typically includes written documentation of findings
• Often performed by specialists in narrow fields

Technology has expanded appraisal options beyond traditional in-person services. Understanding the differences helps you choose the right approach for your needs.

In-Person Appraisals

Traditional face-to-face appraisals offer several advantages:

Benefits:

• Thorough examination: Appraiser can handle items, check construction details
• Detection of repairs/alterations: Some condition issues only visible through physical inspection
• Complete assessment: Dimensions, weight, and other physical characteristics directly measured
• Authentication confidence: Better ability to verify authenticity and materials
• Immediate feedback: Direct conversation about findings and recommendations

Limitations:

• Scheduling constraints: Must coordinate convenient times for both parties
• Geographic limitations: May be difficult to find specialists in certain areas
• Higher costs: Typically more expensive than digital alternatives
• Travel requirements: Either you or the items must travel

Online Appraisal Services

Digital appraisal options continue to expand:

Benefits:

• Convenience: No need to transport items or schedule appointments
• Access to specialists: Can reach experts regardless of geographic location
• Lower cost: Generally more affordable than in-person services
• Quick turnaround: Many digital services provide faster results
• Preliminary screening: Helps determine if items warrant more formal appraisal

Limitations:

• Reliance on photos: Quality and completeness of your photos impact accuracy
• Limited examination: Appraiser cannot physically inspect construction or condition
• Authentication challenges: Harder to detect fakes or alterations
• Less formal documentation: May not meet requirements for insurance or tax purposes

Choosing Between Options

Consider these factors when deciding:

• Value of items: Higher-value items generally warrant in-person examination
• Purpose of appraisal: Insurance and tax purposes typically require formal in-person appraisals
• Item fragility: Delicate or large items may be better assessed on-site
• Authentication concerns: If provenance or authenticity is critical, choose in-person
• Budget constraints: Online options provide more affordable preliminary assessments
• Urgency: Digital services often provide faster turnaround

While local independent appraisers often provide excellent service, several established companies and services have built strong reputations in the antique appraisal industry.

National Appraisal Companies

These organizations operate across multiple regions:

• WorthPoint: Combines a vast price database with professional appraisal services
• Heritage Auctions Appraisal Services: Affiliated with the auction house, offers formal appraisals
• Sotheby’s Valuations: High-end appraisals from the prestigious auction house
• Freeman’s Appraisal Services: America’s oldest auction house offers comprehensive appraisals

Regional Standouts

Some well-reviewed regional providers include:

• Antique Trader Appraisals (Denver, CO): Offers “the finest affordable antique and art appraisal services in the area”
• Peenstra Antique Appraisals (Annapolis, MD): Highly rated with 4.9/5 stars from 258 reviews
• Time Traveler Antiques And Appraisals: 4.6/5 stars from 17 reviews
• Nostalgia Antique Appraisal Services: Specializes in 18th to early 20th century antiques

Celebrity Appraisers

Some appraisers have gained recognition through media appearances:

• Dr. Lori Verderame: Offers in-home appraisals at $999 for one hour when in your area
• Leigh Keno: Known from Antiques Roadshow, offers high-end appraisal services
• Leslie Hindman: Founded one of the nation’s leading auction houses with appraisal services

Auction House Appraisal Services

Major auction houses typically offer appraisal services:

• Christie’s Appraisals: Prestigious auction house with extensive expert network
• Bonhams Valuations: International auction house with specialist departments
• Kaminski Auctions: Boston-area auction house offering professional appraisals

Proper preparation ensures you’ll get the most accurate and comprehensive appraisal possible while maximizing the appraiser’s time.

Gathering Documentation

Collect any available information about your items:

• Receipts or purchase information: Original purchase date and price
• Provenance documents: Letters, certificates, or other historical documentation
• Previous appraisals: Any earlier valuations, even if outdated
• Family history: Written or recorded stories about the items
• Repair records: Documentation of any restoration or repair work
• Photos: Historical photographs showing the item in context or original condition

Organizing Your Items

Prepare your items for efficient examination:

• Clean gently: Remove dust with appropriate methods (no harsh cleaning)
• Group by category: Arrange similar items together
• Create an inventory list: Preliminary list of items to be appraised
• Ensure accessibility: Make sure items can be easily viewed from all angles
• Prepare display area: Clean, well-lit space with room to examine items
• Gather components: Ensure all parts and pieces are available

Questions to Prepare

Be ready to discuss:

• Origin story: How and when you acquired the item
• Known history: Any information about previous owners
• Family connections: Relationship to any notable individuals
• Geographic significance: Regions or locations associated with the item
• Condition changes: Any damage, repairs, or alterations since acquisition
• Your appraisal goals: Clear understanding of why you want the appraisal

Logistical Considerations

Plan the practical aspects:

• Appointment timing: Schedule enough time without rushing
• Space requirements: Ensure adequate room for examination
• Lighting needs: Good natural light or bright artificial lighting
• Work surface: Clean, stable table or counter for examination
• Photo area: Clear space for documentation photographs
• Payment method: Confirm acceptable payment forms

Once you’ve received your appraisal, several important steps will help you maximize its value and ensure proper use of the information.

Reviewing the Appraisal Report

Carefully examine the appraisal document:

• Verify accuracy: Check that all items are correctly identified and described
• Understand methodologies: Review how values were determined
• Note limitations: Be clear about any stated limitations or assumptions
• Check credentials: Confirm the appraiser’s qualifications are listed
• Verify compliance: Ensure the report meets requirements for your intended purpose
• Check expiration: Note any stated validity period for the valuation

Documentation and Storage

Properly preserve your appraisal document:

• Digital backup: Scan or photograph the complete appraisal
• Multiple copies: Store copies in different locations
• Secure storage: Keep original in fireproof safe or safety deposit box
• Insurance company copy: Provide copy to insurance company if for coverage
• Attorney copy: Share with estate attorney if for estate planning
• Organization system: Create filing system for appraisals and related documents

Acting on Appraisal Results

Depending on your goals, next steps might include:

• Insurance adjustments: Update coverage based on appraised values
• Estate planning: Incorporate values into will or trust documents
• Sale decisions: Determine whether to sell based on market value
• Tax planning: Work with accountant on donation or estate tax implications
• Collection adjustments: Refocus collecting priorities based on value insights
• Conservation actions: Address preservation needs identified during appraisal
• Authentication follow-up: Pursue additional authentication if recommended

Scheduling Future Updates

Appraisals have limited validity periods:

• Calendar reminder: Set reminder for reappraisal based on appraiser’s recommendation
• Market monitoring: Follow auction results for similar items
• Value tracking: Note significant market changes in your category
• Condition updates: Document any changes in condition
• Insurance requirements: Note insurance company’s reappraisal requirements

Building Appraiser Relationships

Cultivate an ongoing relationship with your appraiser:

• Provide feedback: Share how the appraisal met your needs
• Ask questions: Follow up on any points requiring clarification
• Future acquisitions: Consider consulting before major purchases
• Stay connected: Join mailing list or follow on social media for market updates
• Referrals: Recommend to others if service was satisfactory

Antique appraisal costs vary depending on several factors, including the appraiser's expertise and reputation, your location, and the type of appraisal needed. According to industry standards:

- Formal appraisals for a single item typically start at $250-$350
- Additional items generally add $25-$100 per item, depending on complexity
- Hourly rates for professional appraisers range from $100-$300 per hour
- In-home appraisal services, like those offered by Dr. Lori, can cost $999 or more
- Appraisal events at antique shows may offer quick verbal assessments for $15-50 per item

For insurance or tax purposes, expect to pay more for the detailed documentation required.

There are several approaches to determining the value of your antiques:

1. **Professional appraisal**: The most accurate method is hiring a certified appraiser specializing in your item type
2. **Auction house evaluation**: Major auction houses like Heritage Auction offer complimentary auction assessments for items they might sell
3. **Antique dealer consultation**: Local dealers may offer informal opinions, but be aware they may have an interest in purchasing
4. **Research comparable sales**: Auction records, price guides, and online databases like WorthPoint can provide reference points
5. **Online valuation services**: Digital platforms offer preliminary assessments based on photographs
6. **Appraisal events**: Museums, antique shows, and charitable events sometimes host appraisal days

For valuable items or those needed for insurance, tax, or estate purposes, a professional written appraisal is strongly recommended.

To have your antiques professionally valued:

1. **Determine your purpose**: Insurance, sale, estate planning, or curiosity
2. **Find a qualified appraiser**: Use professional organization directories or local recommendations
3. **Verify credentials**: Ensure they have proper certification and specialization in your item type
4. **Gather documentation**: Collect any provenance information, receipts, or historical documentation
5. **Prepare your items**: Clean gently and ensure all components are available
6. **Schedule an appointment**: Arrange for in-person examination or follow guidelines for online submission
7. **Ask questions**: Discuss the appraisal process and what information will be provided
8. **Review the results**: Carefully examine the valuation and supporting documentation

For preliminary research, you can also visit local antique shops to talk with dealers and research comparable sales online.

Finding a reputable, honest antique appraiser requires research and due diligence:

1. **Verify professional affiliations**: Look for membership in recognized organizations like ISA, ASA, or AAA
2. **Check certification status**: Ensure they have USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice) compliance
3. **Investigate specialization**: Find someone with expertise in your specific item category
4. **Review qualifications**: Research their education, experience, and background
5. **Check for conflicts of interest**: Avoid appraisers who offer to buy items they appraise
6. **Read reviews and testimonials**: Check multiple sources for consistent positive feedback
7. **Ask for references**: Request and contact previous clients
8. **Examine sample reports**: Review (redacted) samples of their appraisal documentation
9. **Interview potential appraisers**: Discuss their approach and methodology before committing
10. **Trust your instincts**: If something feels unprofessional, seek another opinion

Remember that a quality appraiser will be transparent about their methods, clear about their fee structure, and willing to explain their qualifications.

While professional written appraisals always come with a fee, several options exist for free or low-cost preliminary valuations:

1. **Auction house evaluations**: Many auction houses offer free assessments of items they might be interested in selling
2. **Museum appraisal events**: Some museums host "Antiques Roadshow"-style events where experts give verbal opinions
3. **Antique shows**: Many shows include appraisal booths with nominal fees ($5-20 per item)
4. **Dealer opinions**: Some dealers offer informal assessments, though be aware of potential purchase interest
5. **Online forums**: Collector communities sometimes provide general guidance (though accuracy varies greatly)
6. **Library resources**: Price guides and reference books at public libraries can provide benchmark values
7. **Television appraisal shows**: Programs like Antiques Roadshow occasionally visit different regions

Remember that free appraisals typically provide only verbal opinions without documentation and may not be suitable for insurance, tax, or legal purposes.

A professional, comprehensive antique appraisal should include:

1. **Detailed item description**: Thorough description including measurements, materials, and construction
2. **Maker identification**: Artist, manufacturer, or origin information when known
3. **Age determination**: Estimated date or period of creation
4. **Condition assessment**: Detailed notes on condition, damage, repairs, and alterations
5. **Photographs**: Multiple high-quality images documenting the item
6. **Provenance information**: History of ownership, if known
7. **Value conclusion**: Clearly stated value with specified valuation type (replacement, fair market, etc.)
8. **Valuation methodology**: Explanation of how the value was determined
9. **Comparable sales data**: References to similar items and their sale prices
10. **Appraiser credentials**: The appraiser's qualifications and certifications
11. **Signature and date**: Formal authentication of the document
12. **Purpose statement**: Clear indication of the appraisal's intended use
13. **Limiting conditions**: Any factors that affected the appraisal process

For legal, insurance, or tax purposes, the appraisal must also meet specific formatting and methodology requirements.

Conclusion

Finding the right antique appraiser in your area requires research, but the investment of time and money is worthwhile when you need accurate valuations for insurance, estate planning, or potential sales. By understanding the appraisal process, checking credentials, and preparing properly, you’ll ensure the most accurate and useful results.

Whether you choose a local independent appraiser, work with a national service, or start with an online consultation, the key is finding a qualified professional with expertise in your specific type of antiques. Remember that different appraisal purposes require different approaches and documentation standards, so clarify your needs from the beginning.

With the right antique appraiser, you’ll gain valuable insights into your treasured possessions, make informed decisions about their future, and potentially discover hidden gems in your collection.

Find ISA-certified appraisers specializing in antiques and collectibles in your area.

Directory of ASA-accredited appraisers with advanced search capabilities.

Denver-based appraisal service offering affordable antique and art appraisals.

Find BBB-rated antique appraisal businesses in your region.

Detailed information about appraisal pricing and cost factors.

Expert advice on determining antique values from professional appraisers.

Practical tips for researching and valuing antique items.

Step-by-step guide to locating and choosing qualified antique appraisers.