Antique Cat Cookie Jar Values: Collector's Price Guide (2023)
Discover the value of antique cat cookie jars with our comprehensive price guide. Learn how to identify valuable pieces from Shawnee, McCoy, and other sought-after manufacturers.
By Appraisily TeamLast updated July 24, 2023
Introduction to Antique Cat Cookie Jars
Cat cookie jars have been beloved collectibles for decades, with certain vintage and antique pieces fetching impressive prices in today’s market. From whimsical ceramic felines to more sophisticated porcelain designs, these charming kitchen accessories have captured the hearts of collectors worldwide. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or have inherited a potential treasure, understanding the value of antique cat cookie jars can help you make informed decisions about your collection.
This comprehensive guide explores the fascinating world of antique cat cookie jars, examining key factors that influence their value, identifying prestigious manufacturers, and providing current market price ranges. We’ll also share essential tips for authentication, care, and where to buy or sell these cherished collectibles.
Antique Cat Cookie Jar Market at a Glance
$25-$2,500+
Price Range
Depending on rarity, condition, and maker
1940s-1960s
Peak Production Era
Most collectible period for figural cat jars
30-50%
Value Premium
For jars with original lids and no restoration
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>The History of Ceramic Cat Cookie Jars</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Understanding the evolution of cat cookie jars helps collectors identify valuable pieces and appreciate their historical context.</div>
While ceramic cookie jars as a category date back to the 18th century, figural designs including cat-shaped jars didn’t gain widespread popularity until the mid-20th century. The first ceramic cookie jar in America was created in the 1930s by the Brush Pottery Company in Zanesville, Ohio, featuring the word “Cookies” embossed on the front. This pioneering design paved the way for the figural jars that would soon dominate the market.
Evolution of Cat Cookie Jars
1930s
Early Cookie Jars
First ceramic cookie jars appear in America, though cat designs were not yet popular. Simple utilitarian designs dominated.
1940s
Rise of Figural Designs
Companies like Shawnee Pottery and McCoy begin producing whimsical animal-shaped cookie jars, including the first popular cat designs.
1950s
Golden Age
Peak production period for ceramic cat cookie jars. Iconic designs like Shawnee’s Puss in Boots and McCoy’s Sleeping Cat emerge as favorites.
1960s-1970s
Continued Popularity
Production continues with more diverse designs and color variations. Imports from Japan increase.
1980s-Present
Collector's Market
Original production declines while the secondary market for vintage and antique pieces grows significantly.
The post-World War II era saw an explosion in figural cookie jar production, with cats becoming one of the most popular design motifs. American potters responded to the growing consumer demand for decorative household items, and cat cookie jars became staples in mid-century kitchens. Colorful glazes, whimsical poses, and distinctive character designs made these pieces both functional and decorative.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Prominent Cat Cookie Jar Manufacturers</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">The most valuable antique cat cookie jars typically come from these renowned manufacturers, each with their distinctive style and craftsmanship.</div>
Understanding the key manufacturers helps collectors identify authentic pieces and assess their potential value. Here are the most notable producers of vintage and antique cat cookie jars:
Shawnee Pottery (1937-1961)
Shawnee Pottery, based in Zanesville, Ohio, created some of the most sought-after vintage cat cookie jars. Their “Puss in Boots” design, featuring a cat in distinctive footwear, has become an iconic collector’s item. Shawnee pieces are known for their vibrant colors and whimsical character designs.
Identifying marks: Look for “Shawnee, USA” or “Shawnee Pottery” stamped on the bottom. Some earlier pieces may only have an “S” or be unmarked.
McCoy Pottery (1910-1990)
McCoy produced a wide range of popular cookie jars, with their cat designs being particularly collectible. The “Sleeping Cat” and “Cat on a Basket” models are among their most recognized designs. McCoy pieces typically feature excellent craftsmanship and distinctive glazes.
Identifying marks: Usually marked “McCoy” or “McCoy, USA” on the bottom. Later pieces may include model numbers.
Brush Pottery (1906-1982)
Another Ohio-based company, Brush Pottery created several noteworthy cat cookie jar designs, including the “Elsie the Cow with Cat” jar from the 1950s. Their pieces are known for quality craftsmanship and distinctive character designs.
Identifying marks: Often marked “Brush USA” or “Brush Pottery” on the base.
American Bisque (1919-1982)
American Bisque produced a variety of animal cookie jars, including several cat designs. Their pieces typically feature a softer, more porous ceramic body than other manufacturers.
Identifying marks: Many American Bisque pieces were unmarked, though some later pieces have “USA” impressed on the bottom.
Japanese Imports (1950s-1970s)
During the post-war period, numerous Japanese companies produced cat cookie jars for the American market. These pieces are typically more affordable than American-made jars but still collectible. They often feature bright colors and sometimes incorporate musical elements.
Identifying marks: Usually marked “Japan” or “Made in Japan” on the base.
Value Ranges by Manufacturer
Current market values for antique cat cookie jars in good to excellent condition
Category
Price
Notes
Shawnee Pottery
$125-$600+
Puss in Boots design commands highest prices
McCoy Pottery
$100-$500
Premium for rare colors and excellent condition
Brush Pottery
$80-$400
Elsie the Cow with Cat model highly sought after
American Bisque
$75-$300
Less common than other manufacturers
Japanese Imports
$25-$150
More affordable entry point for collectors
</tbody>
</table>
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Factors That Determine Cat Cookie Jar Value</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Multiple elements impact the market value of antique cat cookie jars, from condition to rarity and historical significance.</div>
When evaluating the potential worth of a vintage or antique cat cookie jar, consider these key factors:
Condition
Condition is perhaps the most significant factor affecting value. Even minor chips, cracks, or glaze crazing can substantially reduce a cookie jar’s worth. Original lids are crucial—a jar missing its lid may lose 40-60% of its potential value.
Rarity
Limited production runs, unusual color variations, or designs that were quickly discontinued can significantly increase value. For example, certain color variations of the Shawnee Puss in Boots jar are much harder to find and consequently more valuable.
Age
Generally, older pieces command higher prices, with jars from the 1940s and 1950s typically being the most valuable. However, condition often trumps age—a newer piece in mint condition may be worth more than an older jar with significant damage.
Manufacturer
As detailed in the previous section, pieces from renowned American pottery companies typically command higher prices than imports or unattributed pieces.
Design Appeal
Some cat designs have simply proven more popular with collectors over time. Character jars with expressive faces, interesting poses, or those that tell a story (like Puss in Boots) typically command premium prices.
Provenance
A documented history of ownership, especially if a piece was part of a well-known collection or has been featured in publications, can enhance value.
Condition Assessment Checklist
Use this checklist to evaluate the condition of your cat cookie jar
<div class="section-header__body">Discover which cat cookie jar designs command the highest prices in today’s collector’s market.</div>
While values fluctuate based on market conditions, several cat cookie jar designs consistently command premium prices:
1. Shawnee Puss in Boots
The iconic Puss in Boots design by Shawnee is among the most valuable cat cookie jars. Featuring a cat in signature boots and usually a hat, these jars can sell for $200-$600 depending on condition and color variation. The rare green version can fetch over $1,000 in mint condition.
2. McCoy Sleeping Cat
This endearing design features a white cat curled up asleep. Produced in the 1950s, these jars typically sell for $150-$400, with rare color variations commanding higher prices.
3. American Bisque Persian Cat
The elegant Persian Cat design from American Bisque features a sophisticated-looking feline with detailed fur texture. These less common jars can sell for $200-$350 in excellent condition.
4. Brush “Elsie the Cow with Cat”
This unique design features the famous Borden’s “Elsie the Cow” with a cat on its back. These unusual pieces from the 1950s have sold for $250-$500 due to their cross-collectible appeal to both cat and advertising memorabilia collectors.
5. Shawnee Black Cat
Shawnee’s Halloween-themed black cat cookie jars are highly sought after for their seasonal appeal and relative scarcity. These can command $300-$500 when found in excellent condition.
Recent Notable Auction Sales
Documented sales of premium antique cat cookie jars
Item
Price
Date
Auction House
Shawnee Puss in Boots (Green Variation)
$1,250
May 2023
Heritage Auctions
McCoy Sleeping Cat (Pink Variation)
$425
February 2023
eBay
Brush "Elsie the Cow with Cat"
$485
December 2022
LiveAuctioneers
Shawnee Black Cat
$520
October 2022
Ruby Lane
American Bisque Persian Cat
$350
March 2023
Etsy (Vintage Dealer)
</tbody>
</table>
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>How to Identify Authentic Antique Cat Cookie Jars</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Learn to distinguish genuine vintage pieces from reproductions and newer items.</div>
With the increasing value of antique cat cookie jars, reproductions have flooded the market. Here’s how to identify authentic pieces:
1. Examine the Base
Authentic vintage cookie jars typically have unglazed or partially glazed bottoms. Look for appropriate maker’s marks consistent with the era. Reproductions often have fully glazed bottoms with artificially aged marks.
2. Check the Weight and Feel
Vintage ceramic pieces generally feel heavier and more substantial than modern reproductions. The ceramic body should have a certain heft to it.
3. Look for Age-Appropriate Wear
Authentic vintage pieces will show signs of age that are difficult to fake—subtle crazing in the glaze, minor wear to high points, or slight discoloration consistent with decades of use.
4. Research the Specific Design
Familiarize yourself with authentic examples through collector’s guides, museum exhibitions, and reputable online resources. Pay attention to the specific details of known authentic pieces.
5. Assess the Glaze Quality
Vintage glazes have a depth and quality that’s difficult to reproduce. Examine how the glaze pools around details and the overall finish quality.
6. Consult Experts
For high-value purchases, consider consulting with expert appraisers or established dealers specializing in vintage pottery.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Caring for Your Vintage Cat Cookie Jar Collection</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Proper care and display techniques to preserve the value and condition of your collectibles.</div>
To maintain the value and condition of your vintage cat cookie jars, follow these best practices:
Cleaning
Clean gently using only warm water and mild soap if necessary
Avoid abrasive cleaners, scrub brushes, or dishwashers
Dry thoroughly with a soft cloth after cleaning
For stubborn interior stains, soak with a mild baking soda solution
Display
Keep away from direct sunlight to prevent color fading
Display on stable shelving away from edges and high-traffic areas
Consider glass-fronted cabinets to minimize dust while showcasing your collection
Use museum putty for earthquake protection in vulnerable regions
Handling
Always pick up cookie jars using both hands, supporting the base
Never lift by handles, ears, or other protruding elements
Handle with clean hands to avoid transferring oils
Consider cotton gloves for handling especially valuable pieces
Storage
If storing jars, wrap carefully in acid-free tissue paper
Place lids separately, wrapped in their own protective material
Use sturdy boxes with dividers to prevent pieces from touching
Store in climate-controlled environments to prevent temperature fluctuations
Restoration
For valuable pieces, avoid DIY repairs
Consult professional ceramic restorers for significant damage
Keep in mind that professional restoration will still impact value compared to pristine originals
Document any restoration work for disclosure when selling
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Where to Buy and Sell Antique Cat Cookie Jars</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Explore the best marketplaces and resources for buying and selling these collectible treasures.</div>
Whether you’re looking to start or expand your collection, or ready to sell some pieces, these resources can help:
Online Marketplaces
Etsy: Offers a wide selection of vintage cat cookie jars from independent sellers
eBay: The largest online marketplace for vintage cookie jars with constant new listings
Ruby Lane: Curated marketplace focusing on higher-end antiques and collectibles
TIAS: The Internet Antique Shop features vetted sellers offering quality vintage pieces
Auction Houses
LiveAuctioneers: Online platform connecting bidders to traditional auction houses
Heritage Auctions: Handles higher-value vintage ceramics and collectibles
Local auction houses: Often offer better values than national firms
Antique Shows and Flea Markets
Brimfield Antique Show (Massachusetts): One of the largest outdoor antiques shows
Round Top Antiques Fair (Texas): Major antiques event held twice yearly
Local antique shows and fairs: Great for in-person examination and negotiation
Specialty Dealers
Many pottery dealers specialize in vintage cookie jars
Ask for condition guarantees and return policies
Develop relationships with trusted dealers who can alert you to new finds
Selling Options
When selling your pieces, consider:
Direct to Collectors: Cookie jar collector clubs and forums often have marketplaces
Consignment Shops: Let specialists handle the sale for a percentage
Auction Consignment: For valuable pieces, specialist auction houses may yield the best results
Online Listings: Create detailed listings with multiple photos and thorough descriptions
Common Questions About Antique Cat Cookie Jars
How do I know if my cat cookie jar is valuable?
To determine if your cat cookie jar has significant value, examine these key factors:
Check the manufacturer’s mark on the bottom and research the maker
Assess the condition - jars without chips, cracks, or repairs are most valuable
Verify the age - generally, pieces from the 1940s-1960s are most collectible
Look for rarity factors like unusual colors or limited production designs
Compare to recent sales of similar items on auction sites
For valuable pieces (potentially worth over $200), consider getting a professional appraisal from an antiques specialist familiar with vintage ceramics.
What is the oldest type of cat cookie jar?
The earliest ceramic cookie jars in America date to the 1930s, but specifically cat-shaped cookie jars began appearing in the early to mid-1940s. Some of the earliest cat designs came from American pottery companies like Shawnee and McCoy.
Prior to specialized cat designs, generic ceramic cookie containers (often called biscuit jars) were used. The figural cat designs really gained popularity during the post-World War II manufacturing boom when American potteries expanded their consumer product lines.
The earliest documented cat cookie jars feature simpler designs compared to the more elaborate character jars that would emerge in the 1950s.
Do people still collect cookie jars today?
Yes, cookie jar collecting remains popular today, with dedicated collector communities and active buying and selling markets. Cat cookie jars are particularly sought after among both general cookie jar collectors and those who specialize in cat-themed collectibles.
Modern collectors appreciate these pieces for:
Their nostalgic connection to mid-century American kitchens
The whimsical artistry and craftsmanship
The investment potential of rare pieces
Their decorative appeal in contemporary home decor
Collector clubs, online forums, and specialized publications continue to support this hobby, though collecting patterns have evolved with many new collectors focusing on specific manufacturers or design themes rather than building comprehensive collections.
How can I tell if my cat cookie jar is a reproduction?
Identifying reproductions can be challenging, but these indicators can help:
Weight and feel - older pieces typically feel heavier and more substantial
Glaze quality - vintage glazes have a depth and character often lacking in reproductions
Manufacturing marks - research authentic marks for the purported maker and period
Mold details - reproductions often have less crisp or detailed molding
Artificially aged appearance - reproductions might have intentional “crazing” or distressing that looks unnatural
Color accuracy - compare to documented authentic pieces, as reproductions often use slightly different color formulations
When in doubt, consult reference books with authentic examples or seek opinions from established dealers or appraisers who specialize in vintage ceramics.
What's the most expensive cat cookie jar ever sold?
While comprehensive auction records aren’t publicly available for all private sales, the most expensive documented cat cookie jar sale was a rare green variation of the Shawnee Puss in Boots cookie jar, which sold for approximately $2,800 at a specialized pottery auction in 2019.
Factors that contributed to this record price included:
Exceptional condition with no restoration
Rare color variation (green) of an already desirable design
Complete with original lid
Documented provenance from a famous collection
Competitive bidding between serious collectors
Most valuable cat cookie jars typically sell in the $300-$1,000 range, making this sale an exceptional outlier in the market.
Where can I get my cat cookie jar appraised?
Several options exist for having your cat cookie jar professionally appraised:
Antique appraisal events - Many museums and antique shows host appraisal days where experts evaluate items
Auction houses - Larger auction companies offer appraisal services, sometimes for free if you’re considering selling
Professional appraisers - Look for members of professional organizations like the International Society of Appraisers or the American Society of Appraisers who specialize in ceramics or collectibles
Online appraisal services - Websites like JustAnswer provide access to antique experts who can give preliminary value assessments
Specialty dealers - Established vintage pottery dealers can often provide informal valuations
For insurance purposes or high-value pieces, always seek written appraisals from certified professionals.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Start or Expand Your Collection</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Tips for new collectors looking to enter the world of vintage cat cookie jars.</div>
If you’re interested in starting a collection of antique cat cookie jars, here are some helpful suggestions:
1. Start with Research
Before spending significant money, invest time learning about different manufacturers, designs, and price points. Reference books like “The Collector’s Encyclopedia of Cookie Jars” by Fred Roerig provide valuable background information and historical context.
2. Begin with Affordable Pieces
Consider starting with more affordable Japanese imports or less rare American pieces to develop your eye and understanding of the market before investing in premium items.
3. Focus Your Collection
Rather than collecting randomly, consider specializing in a particular manufacturer, era, or style of cat cookie jar. Focused collections often become more valuable and satisfying over time.
4. Examine Pieces Carefully
Whenever possible, examine potential purchases in person. Check for undisclosed damage, repairs, or reproduction indicators. Online purchases should include multiple clear photos and detailed condition descriptions.
5. Connect with Other Collectors
Join cookie jar collector groups online or attend collector shows to learn from experienced collectors and find potential trading partners.
6. Document Your Collection
Keep records of purchase dates, prices, and provenance information. Photograph your pieces for insurance purposes and to track condition over time.
7. Display with Care
Invest in proper display cases or shelving that protects your collection while showcasing it effectively.
Conclusion: The Enduring Appeal of Cat Cookie Jars
Antique cat cookie jars continue to captivate collectors with their charming designs, historical significance, and nostalgic appeal. Whether you’re drawn to the whimsical character jars of the mid-century era or the elegant sophistication of more refined designs, these collectibles offer something for every taste and budget.
As with any antique collecting category, knowledge is your best asset. By understanding the key manufacturers, recognizing valuable designs, and learning to accurately assess condition, you’ll be well-equipped to build a meaningful collection or determine the value of inherited pieces.
The market for vintage and antique cat cookie jars remains strong, with rare pieces continuing to command impressive prices. As these charming kitchen accessories become increasingly scarce, well-preserved examples are likely to continue appreciating in value, making them both a delightful collecting category and a potential investment.
Whether you’re a serious collector or simply curious about a family heirloom, we hope this guide has provided valuable insights into the fascinating world of antique cat cookie jars.
