Antique Scissors Value: A Comprehensive Guide to Collecting and Pricing
Discover the fascinating world of antique scissors values, from identification tips to current market prices. Learn what makes these exquisite tools valuable collectibles.
By Appraisily TeamLast updated November 13, 2023
Antique scissors represent fascinating pieces of functional art that have evolved through centuries of craftsmanship. These tools merge practicality with stunning design elements, making them highly sought after by collectors worldwide. Whether inherited from a family member or discovered at an estate sale, understanding the value of antique scissors can help you appreciate their historical significance and potential worth.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>The History and Evolution of Antique Scissors</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Scissors have been a fundamental tool in human civilization since ancient times, with their design and craftsmanship evolving significantly throughout history.</div>
Scissors date back to ancient Egypt, around 1500 BCE, though the cross-blade design we recognize today emerged in ancient Rome around 100 CE. Throughout the centuries, scissors transformed from crude metal implements to exquisite works of art.
The medieval period saw scissors becoming more specialized, with tailors and other craftspeople using custom-designed scissors for specific tasks. By the 16th and 17th centuries, European scissors had become increasingly ornate, particularly in countries like England, France, and Italy.
The true golden age of scissors craftsmanship occurred during the 18th and 19th centuries, when manufacturers began producing them with elaborately designed handles featuring motifs like birds, flowers, and mythological figures. Sheffield, England became a major production center, while German and French workshops also produced distinctive styles.
Evolution of Scissors Design
1500 BCE
Early Scissors
Ancient Egyptians created the first known scissors, consisting of two bronze blades connected by a thin, curved bronze strip.
100 CE
Cross-Blade Design
Romans developed the cross-blade design with a central pivot point, similar to what we use today.
1500-1700
European Craftsmanship
European scissors became more specialized and decorative, with distinct national styles emerging.
1761
Robert Hinchliffe Innovation
Robert Hinchliffe of Sheffield, England began using cast steel for scissors production, greatly improving quality and durability.
1800s
Victorian Elaboration
The Victorian era saw highly decorative scissors with figural handles, gold inlay, and intricate designs for sewing kits and chatelaines.
Early 1900s
Industrial Production
Mass production techniques made scissors more affordable, though fine examples with handcrafted details remained available.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Types of Antique Scissors and Their Values</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">The value of antique scissors varies significantly based on their type, age, craftsmanship, and condition.</div>
Embroidery and Sewing Scissors
Embroidery and sewing scissors were designed with fine, precise blades for delicate fabric work. The most valuable feature figural handles, often shaped like storks, cranes, or other birds. The stork design, resembling a bird’s beak and legs, remains particularly coveted among collectors.
These specialized scissors can range from $30 for simple designs in good condition to over $500 for rare examples with gold inlay or sterling silver handles.
Tailor’s Shears
Larger than standard scissors, tailor’s shears feature asymmetrical handles designed for cutting fabric while resting on a table. Antique examples from renowned makers like Wiss or Wilkinson can fetch $75-$200 depending on condition and age.
Button Hole Scissors
These specialized scissors feature an adjustable screw that controls the length of the cut, ideal for creating consistent buttonholes. Victorian-era examples with decorative handles can range from $40-$150.
Grape or Fruit Scissors
These decorative scissors were part of Victorian dining services, designed specifically for cutting grape stems at the table. Often made of silver or silver plate with ornate handles, they can command $100-$400 depending on maker and condition.
Candle Scissors
Also known as wick trimmers, these specialty scissors were designed with a small box on one blade to catch the trimmed wick, preventing it from falling and creating a fire hazard. Antique brass or silver examples can range from $50-$300.
<div class="section-header__body">Multiple factors influence the market value of antique scissors, from their aesthetic qualities to their functional condition.</div>
Age and Rarity
Generally, older scissors command higher prices, particularly those from the 18th and early 19th centuries. Limited production examples or those from prestigious makers carry significant premiums.
Materials
Scissors made from precious metals like sterling silver or those with gold inlay are typically more valuable than steel examples. However, high-quality steel scissors from renowned manufacturing centers like Sheffield can still command impressive prices.
Decorative Elements
Ornate elements significantly increase value. Look for:
Scissors from prestigious manufacturers like Wiss, Wilkinson, Sheffield makers, or renowned French producers carry premium values. Always check for maker’s marks, often found on the inside of the blades.
Condition
As with most antiques, condition dramatically impacts value. Original finishes, minimal rust or pitting, and fully functional mechanisms are crucial for maximum value.
Value Factors for Antique Scissors
Provenance
Scissors with documented history, especially those belonging to historical figures or from important collections, can command significantly higher prices than comparable pieces without provenance.
Condition Assessment Checklist
Use this checklist to evaluate the condition of antique scissors
Blades align properly when closed
Scissors open and close smoothly
No significant rust or pitting on metal surfaces
Decorative elements intact without chips or losses
Original finish present (not over-polished)
Pivot screw is original (not a replacement)
Blade edges retain sharpness
No repairs or replaced parts
Original case or box if applicable
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>How to Identify Valuable Antique Scissors</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Knowing what distinguishes valuable antique scissors from ordinary examples can help collectors make informed decisions.</div>
Examining Construction
Early antique scissors (pre-1800) were often handmade with evidence of hammer marks and slight asymmetry. Look for hand-forged construction in the earliest examples.
The pivot area provides important clues. Earlier scissors typically have a simpler pivot design, while Victorian examples often feature more elaborate pivot systems. The quality of the pivot joint often indicates the overall quality of the scissors.
Identifying Materials
Sterling silver scissors should be hallmarked. Common locations include inside the handles or near the pivot. British silver typically features clear hallmarks indicating city of origin, date, and maker.
Steel quality varies significantly. Sheffield steel was renowned for its quality in the 18th and 19th centuries. Look for a brilliant polish and fine-grained appearance in high-quality steel.
Recognizing Notable Makers
Prestigious makers to watch for include:
Wiss (American, established 1848)
R. Heinisch (American, established 1826)
Joseph Rodgers & Sons (Sheffield, established 1682)
William Whiteley & Sons (Sheffield)
Premax (American, early 20th century)
Gebruder Stier (German)
Nogent (French)
Notable Antique Scissors Auction Results
Recent sales of exceptional antique scissors
Item
Price
Date
Auction House
Pair of 18th Century Silver Grape Scissors
$950
December 2022
Christie's
Victorian Gold-Plated Stork Scissors
$720
March 2023
Sotheby's
Rare Sheffield Steel Tailor's Shears c.1820
$625
June 2023
Heritage Auctions
Italian Silver Scissors with Figural Handles
$1,250
September 2022
Bonhams
18th Century Steel Embroidery Scissors with Case
$890
February 2023
Skinner Auctioneers
</tbody>
</table>
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Caring for and Restoring Antique Scissors</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Proper care and maintenance are essential for preserving both the condition and value of antique scissors.</div>
Cleaning and Maintenance
For routine cleaning of steel scissors:
Wipe with a soft, dry cloth to remove dust
Apply a small amount of mineral oil to a cloth and gently wipe the metal surfaces
For light rust, use 0000 steel wool with mineral oil, working very gently
After cleaning, apply a thin coat of renaissance wax for protection
For silver scissors:
Use a soft silver polishing cloth for regular maintenance
Avoid harsh chemical cleaners that can damage patina
For tarnish, use a gentle silver polish specifically formulated for antiques
Always rinse thoroughly and dry completely
Storage Recommendations
Proper storage is crucial for preventing damage:
Store scissors in a climate-controlled environment
Avoid areas with high humidity, which can promote rust
Use acid-free tissue or cloth to wrap scissors
For valuable collections, consider archival storage boxes
Keep scissors in closed position with blade protection
Store different pairs separately to prevent scratching
When to Seek Professional Restoration
While minor cleaning can be done at home, significant restoration should be left to professionals. Consider expert help when facing:
Significant rust or corrosion
Broken or missing parts
Damaged decorative elements
Seized pivot mechanisms
Bent or misaligned blades
Remember that improper restoration can significantly decrease value. For valuable antique scissors, consult with a professional conservator who specializes in metal objects.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Where to Find and Sell Antique Scissors</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Whether you’re building your collection or looking to sell, knowing the right marketplaces can help you find the best values.</div>
Best Places to Purchase
Antique Shops and Shows
Specialized antique dealers often have curated collections of sewing tools and may offer authentication and provenance information.
Online Marketplaces
eBay: Largest selection but requires careful evaluation
Etsy: Many vintage and antique sellers with unique items
Ruby Lane: Specialty antique marketplace with quality control
Auction Houses
For museum-quality pieces, consider major auction houses like Christie’s, Sotheby’s, or specialized auction houses that focus on sewing memorabilia and tools.
Estate Sales and Flea Markets
Patience and knowledge can lead to exceptional finds at estate sales, often at lower prices than retail establishments.
Selling Your Antique Scissors
If you’re looking to sell antique scissors:
Research Comparable Sales: Check recent auction results and current listings for similar items
Document Provenance: Gather any information about history, previous ownership, or authentication
Professional Appraisal: For valuable pieces, consider a formal appraisal
Choose the Right Market: Align your selling platform with the value and rarity of your item
High-value pieces: Auction houses or specialized dealers
Mid-range collectibles: Online marketplaces with strong antique presence
Common items: Local antique shops or general marketplaces
Consignment Options
Many antique dealers offer consignment arrangements, typically taking 30-50% of the final sale price but handling marketing, authentication, and sales process.
External Resources for Antique Scissors Collectors
<div class="section-header__body">Whether you’re a novice or experienced collector, thoughtful approaches to collecting can enhance both enjoyment and potential investment value.</div>
Specialization Strategies
Most successful collectors focus their efforts rather than collecting randomly. Consider specializing by:
Time Period: Focus on a specific era like Victorian or Art Deco
Manufacturing Region: Concentrate on Sheffield, German, or French examples
Type: Specialize in embroidery scissors, tailor’s shears, or another specific form
Design Motif: Collect figural handles like storks, birds, or other themes
Material: Focus on silver, steel, or mixed-metal examples
Specialization allows you to develop deeper expertise and often results in a more cohesive and valuable collection.
Documentation Best Practices
Maintaining thorough records enhances both enjoyment and value:
Catalog Your Collection: Record key details about each piece
Measurements and weight
Material composition
Maker’s marks and inscriptions
Purchase date, source, and price
Condition notes and restoration history
Photograph Thoroughly: Take multiple detailed images of each piece
Overall views from multiple angles
Close-ups of maker’s marks
Detail shots of decorative elements
Before and after restoration (if applicable)
Research and Context: Document any historical information
Attribution research
Historical context
Previous ownership
Comparative examples in museums or books
A well-documented collection is not only more enjoyable but typically commands higher prices if you eventually sell.
Common Questions About Antique Scissors Values
How can I tell if my scissors are genuinely antique?
Generally, scissors made before the 1920s are considered antique. Look for these indicators:
Hand-forged construction with slight asymmetry
Visible file marks on early examples
Solid construction with substantial weight
Simple pivot mechanisms on earlier pieces
Maker’s marks from known historical manufacturers
Materials and design elements consistent with the period
Be aware that many reproductions of popular designs like stork scissors exist. When in doubt, consult with an expert or antique dealer who specializes in sewing implements.
What are the most valuable types of antique scissors?
The most valuable antique scissors typically include:
Silver or gold scissors with hallmarks from prestigious makers
Early (pre-1800) steel scissors in excellent condition
Ornate figural designs, especially those with precious metal inlay
Scissors with royal or aristocratic provenance
Complete sets in original cases, especially those with complementary tools
Unusual specialized forms like combined scissors/watches or scissors with hidden compartments
Museum-quality examples can command $500-$1,000 or more at specialized auctions.
Should I clean or restore my antique scissors?
Cleaning requires caution. For moderately valuable scissors:
Gentle dusting and light oiling is generally safe
Avoid harsh chemicals or abrasives that remove patina
Never use modern metal polishes on antique blades
For valuable pieces, consult a professional conservator. Improper cleaning can significantly reduce value by removing original finishes or patina that collectors prize.
Remember that collectors generally prefer original condition with appropriate patina rather than over-restored pieces that look new.
How do I identify fabric scissors?
Fabric scissors have distinctive characteristics:
Sharp, precisely ground blades with no serrations
Blades that meet perfectly along their entire length
Often have a finer point than general-purpose scissors
Higher-quality steel that maintains a sharp edge
Asymmetrical handles on larger tailor’s shears
Specialized design features for specific fabric tasks
Antique fabric scissors were often marked with the maker’s name and sometimes with "for fabric" or similar designations. Higher-quality examples were designed specifically for professional tailors or seamstresses.
Do people collect scissors?
Yes, scissors collecting is a popular niche within antiques and sewing collectibles. Many collectors specialize in specific types, eras, or designs. Some collectors have hundreds of pairs in their collections.
The appeal includes:
Historical significance as essential tools
Artistic and decorative qualities
Mechanical ingenuity and craftsmanship
Connection to textile arts and domestic history
Relatively affordable entry point compared to some antiques
Active collector communities exist online, and many textile museums feature significant scissors collections.
Where can I sell my vintage scissors?
Options for selling vintage and antique scissors include:
Online marketplaces like eBay, Etsy, and 1stDibs
Local antique shops or antique malls (often on consignment)
Specialty dealers who focus on sewing collectibles
Auction houses for higher-value examples
Collector forums and communities
Craft and sewing shows where collectors gather
For the best results, thoroughly research your scissors before selling, document any provenance, and target markets where collectors of sewing implements are likely to shop.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>The Future of Antique Scissors Collecting</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">As with many antiques markets, scissors collecting continues to evolve with changing collector demographics and interests.</div>
The market for antique scissors remains relatively steady, with particular interest in exceptional examples with unusual designs or excellent craftsmanship. While mass-produced 20th-century scissors remain affordable, rare and historically significant pieces continue to appreciate.
Several trends are shaping the future of scissors collecting:
Increased interest in sewing and textile crafts has introduced new collectors to vintage and antique sewing tools.
Online communities and social media have made information more accessible, helping new collectors develop expertise more quickly.
Cross-collecting with other sewing implements (thimbles, needle cases, etc.) has created stronger demand for complete sets and comprehensive collections.
Greater emphasis on provenance and documentation as collectors become more sophisticated and value historical context.
For investors and serious collectors, focusing on museum-quality pieces with solid provenance offers the best long-term value potential, while casual collectors can still find enjoyment and appreciation in more affordable examples.
Antique scissors continue to offer both aesthetic pleasure and historical connection, making them enduring favorites among collectors of all levels. Whether you’re drawn to their beautiful designs, historical significance, or mechanical ingenuity, these remarkable tools provide a tangible connection to craftsmanship traditions that span centuries.
