There’s nothing wrong with a modern buffet. But if you’re staring at an antique oak buffet with bold “tiger” striping, you’re usually trying to answer two questions: Is it really tiger oak? and what is it worth?
This guide focuses on the fastest, most reliable identification clue: quarter-sawn oak ray fleck. Then it walks through the appraisal checklist for buffets and sideboards—construction, veneer, hardware, finish—and anchors the advice with closed-auction comps.
Two-step intake
Share your tiger oak buffet details with an expert today
Upload a wide shot plus two close-ups of the grain, hardware, and drawer joinery. We’ll confirm quarter-sawn oak, flag veneer and repairs, and explain what those details mean for resale or insurance value.
We store your intake securely, sync it with the Appraisily CRM, and redirect you to checkout to reserve your slot.
Quick answer: what “tiger oak” really means
In most antique furniture listings, “tiger oak” is shorthand for quarter-sawn oak—often American white oak—where the cut exposes medullary rays. Those rays show up as shimmering “flecks” or banded stripes across the grain (commonly called ray fleck).
So the wood isn’t a special tiger species. It’s a way of sawing the log. That’s important for appraisal because it changes both the look and the stability of boards—one reason quarter-sawn oak was prized for case furniture in the “Golden Oak” era (roughly 1890–1915).
The 60-second tiger oak checklist (no tools)
Use this order when you’re checking a buffet in person or photographing it for an online appraisal:
- Ray fleck (not just stripes): bright “flakes” that cross the grain.
- Consistency across parts: doors and drawers should show similar figure if original.
- Edges reveal veneer: quarter-sawn veneer is common on panels; it matters for value.
- Drawer interiors: secondary woods are normal; bright new plywood suggests repairs.
- Finish clues: heavy sanding rounds edges and can flatten the figure.
Quarter-sawn vs. plain-sawn: the pattern difference
Quarter-sawn oak shows ray fleck because the growth rings are oriented closer to vertical. Plain-sawn oak tends to show “cathedral” grain.
Common look-alikes (and how to rule them out)
- Ash: can look striped, but usually lacks the bright ray fleck “flakes.”
- Elm: interlocked grain creates streaks, but it’s wavier and less “flecked.”
- Exotic striped veneers: very high-contrast zebra-like bands; uncommon on classic golden-oak buffets.
- Faux graining / printed laminate: repeating pattern and no pore texture under raking light.
Antique tiger oak buffet appraisal: what drives value
A buffet (sometimes called a server or sideboard) is valued like most antique case furniture: quality + condition + maker outweigh the label. Quarter-sawn figure can help, but it’s one ingredient.
Construction and materials
- Veneer vs. solid: quarter-sawn veneer is common on door panels and drawer fronts; check edges for lifting or chips.
- Drawer joinery: consistent dovetails and tool marks support age; brand-new joints on old wood can signal rebuilds.
- Secondary wood: pine/poplar interiors are normal; modern plywood backs and bases reduce value.
Hardware and originality
Replaced pulls don’t automatically “kill” value—repairs are normal—but original brass/bronze pulls, escutcheons, and mirror hardware are strong positives.
Finish and surface
Collectors pay for crisp edges and strong figure. Heavy sanding can flatten ray fleck and soften carvings. If you’re deciding whether to refinish, consider conservation cleaning first.
Style, maker, and market
Late Victorian and “Golden Oak” buffets (roughly 1890–1915) are widely collected. Higher-style carving, mirror backs, marble tops, and maker attribution can move oak pieces from the low hundreds into four figures.
Recent auction comps (real prices)
Below are three closed-auction reference points. Use them as market context—not a guarantee—because condition, region, and buyer pool swing results.
- Direct Auction Galleries, Inc. (Dec 28, 2024), Lot 542: “R.J. Horner ? Carved Oak Buffet / Hutch.” — $2,000 hammer.
- Premier Auction Galleries (Mar 26, 2022), Lot 85: “American Oak Barley Twist Server Buffet” — $290 hammer.
- Premier Auction Galleries (Oct 28, 2023), Lot 615: “19th C. American Oak Griffin Carved Marble Top Server” — $500 hammer.
Takeaway: higher-style carving and possible maker attribution can push oak case pieces into the four figures, while simpler server/buffet forms trade in the low hundreds.
What to photograph for a tiger oak buffet appraisal
To get a confident wood ID and value range, photograph both the beauty surfaces and the evidence surfaces.
- Full front, full side, and a 45° angle shot (shows depth and profile)
- Close-up of the best ray fleck area (door panel or drawer front)
- Close-up of a damaged corner or edge (shows veneer/solid and condition)
- Inside a drawer (joinery and secondary wood)
- Back of the piece (repairs, replaced panels, labels, shipping marks)
- Any maker labels, stamps, or penciled numbers
Care notes (so you don’t erase the evidence)
- Avoid aggressive sanding: it softens edges and can permanently reduce value.
- Test cleaning first: a mild cleaner and wax can revive “golden oak” without stripping.
- Be cautious with veneer: water and heat can lift it; repairs should be reversible when possible.
When to ask an expert (and what to ask)
If the answer affects money (sale, insurance, estate division), it’s worth getting a second set of eyes—especially when a buffet has been refinished or repaired.
- Pieces with mixed construction (some panels solid, others veneered) and unclear repair history
- Buffets with suspected maker attribution (labels, stamps, distinctive carving)
- Items with replaced backs, rebuilt drawers, or heavy sanding
Ask what evidence they used to confirm quarter-sawn oak (ray fleck) and what condition issues are impacting the value range.
Search variations collectors ask
Readers often search these when researching tiger oak furniture:
- how to tell if wood is tiger oak
- is tiger oak the same as quarter sawn oak
- what does ray fleck look like in oak
- tiger oak buffet value and appraisal checklist
- how to tell oak veneer vs solid oak on antique furniture
- does refinishing antique oak furniture reduce value
- golden oak sideboard dating and value
- how to identify antique oak buffet maker marks
- best photos to send for an online furniture appraisal
Each phrase maps to a section above (ID, construction, condition, and market comps).
References
- USDA Forest Products Laboratory: Wood Handbook
- Fine Woodworking (wood ID and furniture construction)
- U.S. National Park Service Conserve O Gram
Wrap-up
You know it’s tiger oak when the “tiger” look comes from ray fleck—the hallmark of quarter-sawn oak—not from stain or printed grain. From there, value is about the whole package: maker quality, construction, condition, and how much original surface remains. If you’re unsure, a short photo set (front, side, back, drawer joinery, and two grain close-ups) is usually enough for an expert to confirm the wood and give you a price-ready range.