“Identify my artifact” can mean anything from a small metal charm found in a field to a carved object inherited from a grandparent. The good news: most IDs don’t require a lab. They require good photos, scale, and the right sequence of observations so you don’t get stuck guessing.
This guide gives you an appraiser-style workflow: how to document safely, how to narrow the object to a category, which material clues matter, how to read marks and construction, and how to use real auction results to sanity-check value expectations.
Two-step intake
Share your artifact details with an expert today
We route your photos, dimensions, and provenance notes to the right specialist. Expect a written quote and next steps in under 24 hours.
We store your intake securely, sync it with the Appraisily CRM, and redirect you to checkout to reserve your slot.
Before you touch it: safety & legality
Some objects should be handled like a science sample, not a souvenir. If anything looks unstable, powdery, or hazardous, stop and photograph in place before cleaning.
- Safety. Gloves help with fragile surfaces (patinas, paper, textiles). Avoid sniffing unknown powders or residues.
- Do not clean aggressively. Cleaning can erase tool marks, patina layers, maker stamps, and soil context.
- Restricted materials. Objects that may include ivory, tortoiseshell, certain wildlife materials, or cultural patrimony can have sale/export restrictions. Identification should include a “can this legally be sold?” step.
The 10-minute identification workflow (what appraisers actually do)
- Record scale. Photograph with a ruler; note weight if you have a small scale.
- Capture all sides. Front, back, base/underside, and the “working” parts (hinges, seams, sockets).
- Look for marks. Stamps, hallmarks, signatures, inventory numbers, painted characters, labels, or impressed symbols.
- Identify the material family. Wood / metal / ceramic / glass / stone / paper / textile / bone-like / composite.
- Identify manufacturing clues. Handwork vs machine work, joinery, casting seams, molding lines, tool marks.
- Compare to similar known forms. “This is like a pendant / charm / tool / vessel” is more useful than “old.”
- Write a one-sentence catalog description. Material + form + likely origin/date range + notable marks.
Photographing for identification: the shots collectors miss
“Can you identify this?” posts often fail because the photo is flattering, not diagnostic. The goal is to show what a cataloger needs:
- Raking light on texture. Angle a lamp low to reveal carving, impressions, and tooling.
- Macro on edges. Wear patterns at corners and high points tell you if age is consistent.
- One photo with consistent color. A neutral background and a color card prevent misleading hues.
Visual ID gallery: materials & construction clues
Use these reference visuals to compare what you’re seeing. None of these clues is “proof” by itself, but together they narrow the possibilities fast.
Category-specific clues: paper, coins, glass, stone, and bone-like materials
When an object isn’t wood/metal/ceramic, you can still get high-signal clues with close-ups and light.
Marks and manufacturing clues (what to look for, what to ignore)
Marks are powerful, but only when you document them correctly.
- Impressed vs printed. Impressed marks (pressed into clay/metal/wood) behave differently than ink stamps.
- Location matters. Base/underside marks are usually more reliable than front-facing “decorative” text.
- Construction tells. Casting seams, mold lines, and joinery often date an object better than surface decoration.
If your mark is faint, try raking light and multiple angles rather than graphite rubbings (which can contaminate surfaces).
Value framework: why two similar artifacts can be 10× apart
Once you’ve got a reasonable identification, value depends on the market for that category. Appraisers usually weigh:
- Authenticity & attribution. Who made it (or which culture/region), and can that be supported?
- Rarity and demand. Common tourist pieces can be handsome but low value; rare forms or provenanced examples can be strong.
- Condition. Breaks, repairs, replaced parts, heavy cleaning, and repainting usually reduce value.
- Provenance. A documented findspot, collection history, or old labels can dramatically change salability.
- Legality. Restrictions can reduce the buyer pool even when the object is desirable.
Auction comps: what similar artifacts actually sold for
To show how category and documentation affect outcomes, here are three concrete auction results from an “indigenous artifacts” dataset. Prices below are hammer prices in the sale currency (buyers often pay additional premium).
- Smalls Auctions (Australia), July 15, 2024, lot 190 — “Rare early ceremonial paddle, Sepik River, Papua New Guinea” hammered at AUD $400.
- Smalls Auctions, July 15, 2024, lot 170 — “Early bark painting… Central Arnhem Land” hammered at AUD $850.
- Smalls Auctions, July 15, 2024, lot 189 — “Early Mexican death mask” hammered at AUD $130.
Notice the spread: the market rewards scarcity, category demand, and how confidently an object can be described. Your goal when identifying your artifact is to make your description defensible enough that a buyer (or insurer) trusts it.
When to escalate to an expert (and what to send them)
If your object is potentially valuable, restricted, or culturally sensitive, it’s worth getting an expert opinion early. A good intake includes:
- 10–15 photos (including marks and scale)
- Dimensions + weight
- Where it came from (estate, field find, purchase), and any paperwork
- Any repairs, missing parts, or cleaning you’ve done
Even a “not valuable” result can be useful: you’ll know whether to conserve, donate, or sell as a decorative item.
Search variations collectors ask
Readers often Google:
- how to identify an artifact I found in my yard
- what photos do I need to identify my artifact
- how to tell if a carved object is antique or modern
- how to identify unknown maker marks on metal items
- how to tell if pottery is old by glaze crazing
- how to identify a pontil mark on antique glass
- how to tell ivory from bone (Schreger lines)
- how to value an artifact using auction comps
Each question is answered in the identification workflow above.
Key takeaways
- Most “mystery artifact” IDs come from better photos, scale, and marks—not from guessing.
- Material + manufacturing clues narrow the category faster than decoration alone.
- Provenance and legality can matter as much as the object itself for sale and insurance.
- Use auction comps as a reality check, then adjust for condition, attribution, and buyer pool.
References
- General cataloging practice: record scale, all sides, and marks before cleaning.
- Material identification basics used by appraisers (wood grain/end grain, tool marks, patina behavior).
- Auction comp dataset entries cited in-text (Smalls Auctions, July 15, 2024 lots 170, 189, 190).
