| Original Etching "Quiet Waters" |
$4,750 |
March 2022 |
Swann Auction Galleries |
| Pencil Drawing "Brush and Rocks" |
$489 |
October 2021 |
Britannic Auctions |
| Gold Foil Etching "Queen Elizabeth's Review of the Fleet" |
$2,250 |
June 2021 |
A.N. Abell Auction Company |
| Set of 4 Framed Gold Foil Etchings |
$625 |
January 2023 |
Invaluable |
</tbody>
</table>
According to data from MutualArt, the record auction price for a Lionel Barrymore artwork since 2012 is $2,250, achieved for “Queen Elizabeth’s Review of the Fleet” at A.N. Abell Auction Company in 2021.
Key Value Determinants
| 5-10x |
Value difference between original etchings and gold foil reproductions |
| 30-50% |
Premium for complete sets vs. individual prints |
| 25-40% |
Value reduction for prints with condition issues |
Authenticity and Medium
The most significant value factor is whether the piece is an original etching versus a reproduction. As noted by experts at JustAnswer, original works from which the variations of prints were made can sell for $3,000-$6,000, while gold foil reproductions typically bring far less.
Condition Assessment
Lionel Barrymore Artwork Condition Factors
Use this checklist to assess the condition of your Lionel Barrymore print
Signature, Edition, and Provenance
Pieces with authentic Barrymore signatures command significant premiums over unsigned works. Limited editions are more valuable than open editions, with lower edition numbers typically more desirable.
Provenance—the documented history of ownership—can significantly increase value, especially if the artwork has notable previous owners or exhibition history.
Frame and Presentation
Many collectors value Barrymore’s gold foil etchings in their original frames. According to eBay listings, complete framed sets in matching frames typically sell for 30-50% more than unframed prints.
Original Etchings vs. Gold Foil Reproductions
Original Barrymore etchings have distinct characteristics:
- Made on traditional etching paper with a plate impression
- Show fine line detail and tonal variations
- Typically include an artist’s signature in pencil
Gold foil reproductions have different identifying features:
- Printed on foil-backed paper with a metallic appearance
- Often mass-produced after Barrymore’s death
- Usually smaller in size than original etchings
- Typically bear a printed signature rather than an original pencil signature
Examining Publishers and Marks
Authentic gold foil reproductions were primarily published by:
- Brown & Bigelow (most common publisher)
- A.M. Adler, Inc.
- M. Grumbacher, Inc.
Look for publisher information, copyright marks, or identifying labels on the back of the frame or on the print itself. Authentic pieces often have paper labels or stamps indicating the publisher.
Professional Authentication
For high-value purchases or significant original works, consider:
- Professional appraisal from a qualified art appraiser
- Authentication from auction houses specializing in American prints
- Consultation with galleries that specialize in 20th-century American printmaking
Historical Timeline of Lionel Barrymore's Art
-
1920s
Artistic Beginnings
Barrymore begins creating etchings while working in Hollywood films, focusing primarily on maritime and landscape subjects.
-
1930s-1940s
Artistic Peak
Creates his most significant original etchings, exhibiting with the California Society of Etchers and gaining recognition for his artistic talents.
-
1950s
Posthumous Publications
Following Barrymore's death in 1954, publishers begin producing his popular gold foil etchings, making his art accessible to mass audiences.
-
1960s-1970s
Peak Popularity
Gold foil etchings reach their height of popularity as decorative pieces in American homes, with multiple publishers producing various sets.
-
1980s-Present
Collector's Market Develops
Original etchings and vintage gold foil prints become sought-after collectibles, with auction market establishing distinct value tiers for different types of Barrymore artwork.
Online Marketplaces
eBay: According to recent eBay listings, this platform offers the largest selection of Barrymore’s gold foil etchings, with prices typically ranging from $40-$300 for individual prints and $200-$600 for complete sets.
Etsy: Features vintage prints, often with a focus on decorative appeal and framing quality.
Online Auction Platforms: Sites like Invaluable and Barnebys regularly list Barrymore works at various price points.
Traditional Auction Houses
For original etchings and higher-value pieces, established auction houses provide authentication and broader market exposure:
- Heritage Auctions
- Swann Auction Galleries
- Bonhams
- Local regional auction houses often feature Barrymore’s work
Art Dealers and Galleries
Specialized print dealers may offer:
- Expert authentication
- Professional condition assessments
- Premium presentation
- Higher asking prices with dealer guarantees
Estate Sales and Antique Shops
Bargains can sometimes be found at:
- Estate sales
- Local antique shops
- Flea markets
- Thrift stores
These venues often have less price standardization, creating opportunities for knowledgeable collectors.
Investment Considerations
While primarily collected for decorative and nostalgic value, certain Barrymore pieces have shown appreciation:
-
Original etchings: Have demonstrated the strongest price appreciation, with museum-quality examples increasing 30-50% in value over the past decade
-
Vintage gold foil prints: Complete sets in original frames have maintained stable values, particularly for popular maritime scenes
-
Modern reproductions: Generally considered decorative items rather than investment pieces
According to market data from MutualArt, Barrymore’s work has shown steady but modest price growth compared to other printmakers of his era.
Collection Strategies
Focused collectors might consider:
-
Theme-based collecting: Focus on specific subject matter (harbors, fishing boats, coastal scenes)
-
Complete sets: Acquire full matched sets of the gold foil etchings, which typically retain value better than individual prints
-
Condition priority: Invest in pieces with exceptional condition, original frames, and documentation
-
Original works: For serious collectors, focus on acquiring Barrymore’s true etchings rather than reproductions
Preservation Tips
To maintain value and condition:
- Display away from direct sunlight to prevent fading
- Use UV-protective glass or acrylic in framing
- Maintain stable humidity and temperature
- Preserve original frames, mats, and publisher information
- Keep any certificates of authenticity or provenance documentation
Common Questions About Lionel Barrymore Art Value
How can I tell if my Lionel Barrymore print is an original etching or a reproduction?
Original Barrymore etchings have distinctive characteristics:
- They’re printed on high-quality etching paper with visible plate marks (indentations around the image)
- They typically feature an authentic pencil signature (not printed)
- They show fine line detail and subtle tonal variations
- They’re generally larger than the reproduction prints
Most pieces in circulation are gold foil reproductions, which have a metallic appearance and were mass-produced after Barrymore’s death. Original etchings are much rarer and more valuable, often selling for $3,000-$6,000 compared to $50-$300 for reproductions.
What are the most valuable Lionel Barrymore gold foil etchings?
Among the gold foil reproductions, the most valuable pieces typically include:
- Complete matching sets of four prints in original frames
- Rare or less common scenes such as "Queen Elizabeth’s Review of the Fleet"
- Early editions with clear publisher markings from Brown & Bigelow
- Exceptionally well-preserved examples without fading or damage
The popular nautical scenes "Point Mugu," "Old Boat Works," "San Pedro," and "Nantucket" tend to command higher prices, particularly when part of complete sets.
Did Lionel Barrymore sign his artwork?
Yes, Lionel Barrymore did sign his original artwork. His original etchings typically feature his authentic signature in pencil. However, most of his gold foil reproductions have a printed signature rather than an original hand-signed one.
The printed signature on reproductions is part of the printing process, not an original signature. This is one key way to distinguish original etchings from reproductions. Authentic hand-signed Barrymore pieces command significantly higher values in the market.
How much was Lionel Barrymore worth when he died?
According to historical records, Lionel Barrymore had amassed a fortune of approximately $3 million by the time of his death in 1954. In today's currency, that would be equivalent to around $35 million.
While his wealth came primarily from his successful acting career spanning decades in Hollywood, his artistic endeavors also contributed to his legacy. The commercial reproductions of his artwork, particularly the gold foil etchings, became popular after his death and continue to generate interest in the collector’s market today.
Where can I sell my Lionel Barrymore gold foil etchings?
Several marketplace options exist for selling Lionel Barrymore gold foil etchings:
-
Online marketplaces: eBay and Etsy are popular platforms with large audiences for these decorative prints
-
Auction houses: For higher-quality or original pieces, consider auction houses like Heritage Auctions, Invaluable, or local auction services
-
Antique dealers: Local antique shops may purchase or consign your prints
-
Print dealers: Galleries specializing in American prints may be interested in original etchings
Before selling, consider having valuable pieces authenticated and appraised to ensure you receive fair market value.
External Resources for Lionel Barrymore Art Collectors
Conclusion: The Enduring Appeal of Lionel Barrymore’s Art
Lionel Barrymore’s artistic legacy continues to resonate with collectors and decorators alike. While his gold foil etchings represent a fascinating intersection of Hollywood celebrity and artistic talent, they occupy a unique niche in the art market.
For collectors, understanding the distinctions between original etchings and various reproductions is essential for making informed purchasing decisions. While original Barrymore etchings represent significant investments with potential for appreciation, the more common gold foil reproductions are primarily valued for their decorative appeal and connection to a beloved Hollywood icon.
As with any collectible art market, condition, authenticity, and presentation remain paramount in determining value. By focusing on quality examples and preserving their original attributes, collectors can enjoy these distinctive artworks while potentially seeing moderate appreciation in value over time.
Whether acquired for investment purposes or simply aesthetic enjoyment, Lionel Barrymore’s maritime scenes continue to evoke nostalgia and admiration for an actor whose artistic talents extended well beyond the silver screen.
