Appraisily

August 10, 2023

Old Cabin Whiskey Bottle Value: Collector's Guide to Pricing & Authenticity

Discover the true value of Old Cabin Whiskey bottles with our comprehensive guide covering rare originals worth thousands to common reproductions selling for under $20.

Authentic E.G. Booz's Old Cabin Whiskey bottle from 1840s Philadelphia showing cabin-shaped design
By Appraisily Team Last updated August 10, 2023

The distinctive cabin-shaped E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottle stands as one of the most recognizable and sought-after antique spirits bottles in the collector’s market. With values ranging from just a few dollars to several thousand, determining what your bottle is actually worth requires understanding its age, authenticity, and condition.

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>The History of E.G. Booz&#39;s Old Cabin Whiskey</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Before assessing value, it&rsquo;s important to understand the fascinating history behind these distinctive bottles and why they&rsquo;ve become so collectible.</div>

E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey originated in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in the 1840s. Edmund G. Booz, a Philadelphia distiller, commissioned the distinctive cabin-shaped bottles as a marketing innovation, creating what would become one of America’s earliest branded whiskey containers.

The unique cabin design represented frontier values and pioneer spirit during a time when log cabins symbolized American authenticity. Interestingly, some historians suggest the term “booze” as slang for alcohol may have originated from the Booz whiskey brand, though this remains debated.

E.G. Booz's Old Cabin Whiskey Timeline

  1. 1840

    Original Production

    Edmund G. Booz begins selling his whiskey in the distinctive cabin-shaped bottles in Philadelphia.
  2. 1860s-1870s

    Original Production Ends

    Original production of the authentic E.G. Booz's Old Cabin Whiskey bottles ceases.
  3. Early 1900s

    First Reproductions

    The first wave of reproductions begins, with manufacturers creating copies of the popular bottle design.
  4. 1960s-1970s

    Wheaton Glass Reproductions

    Wheaton Glass Company produces large quantities of reproduction bottles in various colors, including blue, amber, and green.
  5. 2000s-Present

    Collector's Market Develops

    Values for authentic 19th century bottles soar while reproductions remain common in the affordable collectibles market.
<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Identifying Authentic vs. Reproduction Bottles</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">The most critical factor in determining the value of an Old Cabin Whiskey bottle is authenticity. Genuine 19th-century bottles are exceedingly rare and valuable, while 20th-century reproductions are common and relatively inexpensive.</div>

Distinguishing between original 19th-century E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottles and later reproductions is crucial for accurate valuation. According to the Federation of Historical Bottle Collectors Virtual Museum, these key characteristics can help identify authentic bottles:

Authentication Checklist for Original Bottles

Genuine 19th century E.G. Booz bottles will typically have these characteristics:

  • Amber or olive-amber glass coloration
  • Correct embossing with 'E.G. BOOZ'S OLD CABIN WHISKEY 1840'
  • Visible pontil mark on the bottom
  • Crude, hand-blown appearance with bubbles in glass
  • Dimensions approximately 7.5 inches tall
  • Weight of glass feels substantial and heavy
  • Seams that don't extend fully to the top
  • Irregularities and asymmetry in the molding

For reproduction bottles, look for these telltale signs:

  1. Modern Glass Colors: Blue, bright green, or perfectly clear glass indicate 20th-century reproductions, particularly from the Wheaton Glass Company.

  2. Different Embossing: Reproductions often have slight variations in the embossing, such as “E.C. BOOZ’S” rather than “E.G. BOOZ’S” or missing the apostrophe entirely.

  3. Modern Manufacturing Marks: Perfectly symmetrical seams, lack of bubbles in the glass, or machine-made marks point to reproduction.

  4. “Wheaton” or Other Markings: Many reproductions were explicitly marked with company names or “REPRODUCTION” on the base.

  5. Japan/Taiwan Origin: Some reproductions are marked “Made in Japan” or “Made in Taiwan” on the bottom.

According to Historic Glasshouse, even among collector communities, many people have never seen an authentic original bottle in person due to their rarity.

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Value Factors &amp; Price Ranges</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">The market value of Old Cabin Whiskey bottles varies dramatically based on authenticity, condition, color, and provenance. Let&rsquo;s explore the key valuation considerations and current market prices.</div>

According to auction records and expert appraisals, the value of E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottles falls into several distinct categories:

Market Value Overview

Old Cabin Whiskey Bottle Value Ranges

Current market prices as of 2023

  </tbody>
</table>

As evidenced by recent auction results, original bottles in good condition continue to command impressive prices. According to Heckler Auction, an authenticated original E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottle from the 1840s sold for $8,775 in recent years. Meanwhile, LiveAuctioneers reports reproduction bottles selling for as little as $79.99 for an entire lot of 19 pieces.

Several key factors impact the value of these bottles:

  1. Condition: Even among authentic bottles, condition dramatically affects value. Look for:

    • Absence of chips, cracks, or repairs
    • Clarity of the glass (no severe clouding or staining)
    • Integrity of embossing (clear, legible details)
    • Original closures or stoppers (extremely rare)

  2. Color Variations: Among authentic bottles, certain colors are rarer and more valuable:

    • Amber/honey amber (most common among originals)
    • Olive amber (highly desirable)
    • Clear (extremely rare in originals)

  3. Provenance: Documented history of ownership can significantly increase value, especially if:

    • The bottle has been featured in museum exhibitions
    • It comes from a renowned collection
    • It has verified historical documentation

Pair of reproduction E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottles showing color variations

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Where to Buy and Sell Old Cabin Whiskey Bottles</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Finding the right marketplace is crucial whether you&rsquo;re looking to purchase an Old Cabin Whiskey bottle for your collection or sell one you already own.</div>

For Sellers

If you believe you have an authentic 19th-century E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottle, consider these specialized selling options:

  1. Specialized Bottle Auctions: Auction houses that focus on antique bottles and spirits containers often attract serious collectors willing to pay premium prices. Examples include:

  2. High-End Antique Auctions: For potentially valuable authentic examples, major auction houses provide authentication services and access to wealthy collectors:

    • Christie’s
    • Sotheby’s
    • Heritage Auctions

  3. Specialty Bottle Shows: Annual gatherings of bottle collectors can be excellent venues for selling to knowledgeable buyers.

For reproduction bottles, which make up the vast majority of Old Cabin Whiskey bottles in circulation, more general marketplaces are appropriate:

  1. Online Marketplaces: According to current eBay listings, reproduction bottles typically sell in the $9.50-$21.10 range.

  2. Antique Malls and Shops: Local antique dealers may purchase reproduction bottles for resale.

  3. Collector Forums: Online communities like the Federation of Historical Bottle Collectors connect sellers with interested buyers.

For Buyers

When purchasing an Old Cabin Whiskey bottle, your approach should match your collecting goals:

  1. For Serious Collectors: If seeking an authentic original bottle, work with reputable dealers and auction houses that provide:

    • Detailed provenance information
    • Authentication documentation
    • Condition reports
    • Return policies for misrepresented items

  2. For Casual Collectors: If you simply appreciate the distinctive cabin design:

    • Reproduction bottles are readily available on Etsy and similar platforms
    • Prices typically range from $15-30, making them accessible collectibles
    • Various colors (blue, green, amber) are available in the reproduction market

  3. For Decorative Purposes: Many people collect these bottles primarily for their aesthetic value:

    • Modern reproductions make attractive display pieces
    • Can often be found at flea markets, estate sales, and online marketplaces

Close-up of a Wheaton Glass reproduction E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottle in blue glass

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Expert Appraisal Recommendations</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">If you suspect you might have an authentic E.G. Booz&rsquo;s Old Cabin Whiskey bottle, professional appraisal is essential before making buying or selling decisions.</div>

Due to the significant value difference between authentic originals and reproductions, proper authentication is crucial. Consider these professional appraisal options:

  1. Bottle Collecting Organizations: Organizations like the Federation of Historical Bottle Collectors can connect you with knowledgeable experts in antique bottles.

  2. Specialized Appraisers: Seek appraisers with specific expertise in 19th-century American bottles and spirits containers.

  3. Auction House Evaluations: Major auction houses that deal in antiques often offer free initial assessments to determine if an item meets their consignment standards.

  4. Museum Curators: Curators at institutions with glass or Americana collections may provide insights, though formal appraisals are typically outside their scope.

According to JustAnswer Antiques, green E.C. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottles dated 1840 typically have a secondary retail market value of $30-35, confirming they are reproductions rather than originals.

For the most accurate authentication, experts typically examine:

  1. Glass Composition: Using specialized lighting to assess period-correct glass properties
  2. Manufacturing Techniques: Identifying hand-blown vs. machine-made characteristics
  3. Mold Seams: Analyzing seam patterns consistent with 19th-century production methods
  4. Embossing Details: Comparing embossing to documented authentic examples
  5. Wear Patterns: Distinguishing genuine age-related wear from artificial aging

Common Questions About Old Cabin Whiskey Bottles

How can I tell if my Old Cabin Whiskey bottle is authentic or a reproduction? 
Authentic 19th-century E.G. Booz's Old Cabin Whiskey bottles typically feature:

    

  • Amber or olive-amber glass (not blue, bright green, or perfectly clear)
    • 

  • Correct embossing with "E.G. BOOZ’S OLD CABIN WHISKEY 1840"
    • 

  • Visible pontil mark on the bottom
    • 

  • Crude, hand-blown appearance with bubbles in glass
    • 

  • Irregularities and asymmetry in the molding
    • 



Reproductions often have perfect symmetry, different glass colors (especially blue), machine-made marks, or company names like "Wheaton" on the bottom. Many reproductions also have minor variations in the text, such as "E.C. BOOZ’S" instead of "E.G. BOOZ’S."

What is the value range for Old Cabin Whiskey bottles? 
The value ranges dramatically based on authenticity and condition:

    

  • Authentic 19th-century originals: $500-$10,000+, depending on condition
    • 

  • Early 20th-century reproductions: $50-$200
    • 

  • Wheaton Glass reproductions (1960s-1970s): $10-$30
    • 

  • Modern replicas: $5-$20
    • 



According to auction records, a museum-quality original sold for $8,775 at Heckler Auction, while common reproductions typically sell for under $20 on eBay and Etsy.

Is it true that the term 'booze' comes from E.G. Booz's Whiskey? 
While this is a popular claim, the evidence is inconclusive. Some historians suggest the term "booze" as slang for alcohol may have originated or been popularized by the E.G. Booz whiskey brand in the 1840s. However, linguistic research indicates the word may have earlier origins in Middle Dutch "būsen" (to drink heavily) and Middle English "bouse." The Booz brand likely contributed to the term's popularization in American usage, even if it wasn't the original source.
Are blue Old Cabin Whiskey bottles valuable? 
Blue Old Cabin Whiskey bottles are always reproductions, as the original 19th-century bottles were only produced in amber or olive-amber glass. Blue bottles were made primarily by the Wheaton Glass Company in the 1960s-1970s as part of their decorative collectibles line. While they have some collector interest, blue reproduction bottles typically sell for only $15-30, making them decorative rather than valuable investment pieces.
Where can I sell my Old Cabin Whiskey bottle? 
The best selling venue depends on your bottle's authenticity:

    

  • 

    For authenticated originals: specialized bottle auctions (Heckler, American Bottle Auctions), high-end antique auctions (Christie’s, Sotheby’s), or direct sales to serious collectors through specialty bottle shows
    

    • 

  • 

    For reproductions: general online marketplaces (eBay, Etsy), local antique malls, flea markets, or general auction sites
    

    • 



Always be transparent about your bottle’s authenticity status when selling, as misrepresenting reproductions as originals is both unethical and potentially illegal.

Is it worth buying a reproduction Old Cabin Whiskey bottle? 
Reproduction Old Cabin Whiskey bottles can be worthwhile purchases for:

    

  • Decorative purposes - they make attractive display items
    • 

  • Beginning collectors learning about bottle collecting
    • 

  • Completing a collection of Wheaton Glass pieces
    • 

  • Educational purposes to understand bottle designs
    • 



However, they should not be viewed as financial investments, as reproduction bottles have not significantly appreciated in value over time. Expect to pay $10-30 for a typical reproduction bottle, which represents its fair market value.

External Resources for Old Cabin Whiskey Bottle Research

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Conclusion: Is Your Old Cabin Whiskey Bottle a Hidden Treasure?</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">While most Old Cabin Whiskey bottles in circulation today are reproductions with modest value, the possibility of discovering an authentic original creates enduring fascination among collectors.</div>

The E.G. Booz’s Old Cabin Whiskey bottle represents a fascinating piece of American marketing history, creating one of the earliest and most recognizable branded spirits containers. While authentic 19th-century examples are exceedingly rare and valuable—commanding prices in the thousands of dollars—the vast majority of bottles found today are 20th-century reproductions worth between $5 and $30.

For collectors, the joy of these distinctive bottles extends beyond mere monetary value. They connect us to America’s frontier heritage, innovative marketing history, and the evolution of bottle manufacturing techniques. Whether you own an authentic museum-quality original or a colorful Wheaton Glass reproduction, these unique cabin-shaped bottles continue to captivate collectors and decorators alike.

If you believe you might have an authentic example, professional authentication is essential before making any buying or selling decisions. The substantial price differential between originals and reproductions ($5,000+ versus $20) makes expert appraisal a worthwhile investment.

For most collectors, reproduction bottles offer an affordable way to enjoy this iconic design while appreciating the historical significance of E.G. Booz’s marketing innovation that forever changed how spirits were branded and sold in America.

Category Price Notes
Authentic 19th Century Original (Excellent) $5,000-$10,000+ Museum-quality originals in pristine condition
Authentic 19th Century Original (Good) $2,000-$5,000 Original bottles with some wear, chips, or cracks
Authentic 19th Century Original (Poor) $500-$2,000 Heavily damaged but verified authentic bottles
Early 20th Century Reproductions $50-$200 Earlier, better quality reproductions from 1900-1950
Wheaton Glass Reproductions $10-$30 Common colored glass reproductions from 1960s-1970s
Modern Replicas $5-$20 Recent mass-produced decorator bottles