Appraisily

September 18, 2023

Old Crow Whiskey Bottle Value Guide: What Your Vintage Bourbon Is Worth

Discover the value of your Old Crow whiskey bottle with our comprehensive guide covering vintage bottles, rare decanters, and factors that affect collectible bourbon prices.

Vintage Old Crow Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey bottle with original label and tax stamp
By Appraisily Team Last updated September 18, 2023
<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Introduction to Old Crow Whiskey Bottle Values</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Old Crow whiskey, with its rich heritage dating back to the 1830s, has become increasingly collectible among bourbon enthusiasts and bottle collectors. Whether you&rsquo;ve discovered an unopened bottle in your grandfather&rsquo;s liquor cabinet or are considering starting a collection, understanding the value of vintage Old Crow bottles can be both rewarding and potentially profitable.</div>

The value of Old Crow whiskey bottles varies widely based on several factors including age, condition, rarity, and whether the bottle is still sealed with its original contents. From common mid-century bottles worth $50-100 to rare pre-Prohibition examples that can fetch several hundred dollars, the market for Old Crow collectibles offers options for collectors at every level.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore what determines Old Crow whiskey bottle values, highlight particularly valuable editions, and provide you with the knowledge to assess your own vintage bottles.

Old Crow Market Highlights

$140-$180
Sealed 1960s Bottles
For standard 86 proof bottles
$200-$8,000+
Rare Chess Decanters
Depending on piece and condition
$250-$450
Pre-1960s Bottles
Unopened in excellent condition
<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>The Rich History of Old Crow Bourbon</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Before diving into valuation, understanding Old Crow&rsquo;s storied past helps collectors appreciate why these bottles command interest. One of America&rsquo;s oldest bourbon brands, Old Crow has a heritage closely tied to the development of Kentucky bourbon itself.</div>

Old Crow Whiskey Historical Timeline

  1. 1830s

    Creation by Dr. James Crow

    Scottish chemist Dr. James C. Crow developed the sour mash process while working at the Old Oscar Pepper Distillery in Kentucky, creating what would become Old Crow bourbon.
  2. 1860s

    Presidential Popularity

    Old Crow gained fame as a favorite of notable figures including Presidents Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, and literary figures like Mark Twain and Walt Whitman.
  3. 1935

    Post-Prohibition Revival

    After Prohibition, National Distillers acquired the Old Crow brand, producing bottles that are now sought by collectors.
  4. 1987

    Jim Beam Acquisition

    Jim Beam purchased the brand, changing the formula and production methods, creating a distinct difference between pre and post-1987 bottles.
  5. 1960s-1970s

    Collectible Decanters Era

    The brand released a popular series of collectible decanters, especially the highly sought-after chess piece series.

Old Crow’s historical significance contributes significantly to its collectibility. As whiskey historian Thomas P. Breen notes, the brand’s connection to legendary figures makes these bottles not just containers for spirits but historical artifacts representing America’s bourbon heritage.

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Factors Influencing Old Crow Whiskey Bottle Values</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Several key factors determine the value of vintage Old Crow whiskey bottles in today&rsquo;s collector market. Understanding these elements will help you better assess the potential worth of any bottle in your collection.</div>

Age and Era

The era during which your Old Crow bottle was produced significantly impacts its value:

  • Pre-Prohibition bottles (pre-1920): Extremely rare and valuable, often fetching $500-1,000+ even when empty
  • Post-Prohibition to 1987: Bottles from the National Distillers era are prized for their quality and historical significance
  • Post-1987: After Jim Beam’s acquisition, bottles generally have lower collector value unless part of special editions

Bottle Condition

Old Crow Bottle Condition Assessment

Check applicable items to determine your bottle's condition

  • Original seal intact and unbroken
  • Label in excellent condition with minimal fading or tearing
  • Original tax stamp present and legible
  • Fill level above the shoulder of the bottle
  • No leakage or evaporation apparent
  • Cap/cork in good condition
  • Original box or packaging included

Contents Status

  • Sealed with contents: Unopened bottles with original whiskey generally command 2-3 times the value of empty bottles
  • Empty bottles: Still collectible, especially rare designs or older versions with intact labels

Rarity and Special Editions

  • Standard bottles: Common production bottles have modest value ($20-100 empty, $50-200 sealed)
  • Decanters and special editions: Limited production runs, especially the chess set pieces, can command premium prices
  • Regional releases: Bottles distributed only in certain areas may have higher values

According to WineSearcher.com, modern standard Old Crow bottles retail for around $10-25, but vintage examples from earlier decades command much higher prices in the collector market.

Old Crow Whiskey Bottle Value Guide

Current market value ranges based on era and condition

  </tbody>
</table>
<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>How to Date Your Old Crow Whiskey Bottle</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Accurately dating your Old Crow bottle is essential for determining its value. Several identifying marks can help pinpoint the production era of your bottle.</div>

Bottom Markings and Glass Codes

As explained by WhiskeyID.com, bottle bases often contain valuable dating information:

  • Two-digit numbers: Often represent the year of manufacture
  • Manufacturer codes: Symbols or numbers identifying the glass maker
  • Mold numbers: Can help identify production batches

Tax Stamps and Labels

Vintage tax stamp on Old Crow whiskey bottle

  • Red tax stamps: Used from 1934-1985, with variations in design that help date the bottle
  • Tax information: “Series” or “Series of” followed by a year indicates when the tax stamp design was issued, not necessarily the bottling year
  • Label styling: Subtle changes in label design, logo, and text formatting occurred over decades

Bottle Design Changes

  • 1950s-1960s: Often 4/5 quart volume with distinctive sloped shoulders
  • 1970s: Transition to metric measurements (750ml, 1L)
  • Post-1987: Modern bottle styling after Jim Beam acquisition

According to experts at JustAnswer’s Antiques Section, these dating details can significantly impact valuation, with pre-1987 bottles from the National Distillers era being particularly desirable.

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Highly Collectible Old Crow Bottles &amp; Decanters</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Certain Old Crow products stand out as particularly valuable in today&rsquo;s collector market. These special editions and unique bottles often command premium prices.</div>

The Legendary Chess Series

The Old Crow Chess Pieces from the late 1960s and early 1970s are among the most sought-after whiskey decanters ever produced:

  • Individual pieces: Range from $90 for common pieces to $8,000+ for rare pieces like the 1969 Castle with hang tag
  • Complete sets: A full set of chess pieces in excellent condition can sell for $2,000-$10,000
  • Rarity factors: Some pieces were produced in much smaller quantities, increasing their value

Ceramic Specialty Bottles

Old Crow ceramic specialty whiskey bottle

  • Vintage ceramic decanters: Standard decorative ceramic bottles typically value at $65-150 depending on condition and design
  • Top hat design: The distinctive ceramic bottle with a top hat stopper sells for approximately $75 in excellent condition
  • Novelty shapes: Various special edition bottles featuring unique designs command higher prices

Historic Gallon Bottles

  • One-gallon glass bottles: Large format bottles from the 1950s-1970s are collector favorites
  • Complete with handle: Original handle intact increases value significantly
  • Value range: $50-150 empty, $200-400 sealed in good condition

Specialty retailer Collins & Coupe notes that condition is particularly crucial for ceramic pieces, with intact original stoppers and minimal wear commanding top dollar.

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Where to Buy and Sell Old Crow Collectibles</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">If you&rsquo;re looking to buy or sell vintage Old Crow bottles, several established marketplaces cater to whiskey collectors.</div>

Online Marketplaces

Auctions and Specialty Retailers

  • Whiskey auctions: Both online and in-person auctions frequently feature rare Old Crow items
  • Antique shops: Often have empty collectible bottles at reasonable prices
  • Specialty liquor retailers: Some high-end liquor stores carry vintage spirits

Valuation Services

Before selling, consider getting an expert appraisal:

  • Professional appraisers: Can provide certified valuations for insurance or sale
  • Online appraisal services: Sites like JustAnswer offer expert opinions on bottle values
  • Auction house evaluations: Many auction houses provide free assessment of potential items for sale
<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Caring for Your Vintage Whiskey Collection</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">Proper storage and handling can preserve both the condition and value of your Old Crow collection.</div>

Storage Recommendations

  • Temperature: Store at consistent, cool temperatures (55-65°F)
  • Light exposure: Keep bottles away from direct sunlight to prevent label fading
  • Position: Store upright to minimize contact between the whiskey and cork/cap
  • Humidity: Moderate humidity (50-70%) helps prevent labels from drying and cracking

Display Considerations

  • UV-filtered cases: Display cases with UV protection preserve label colors
  • Secure shelving: Ensure bottles are stable and protected from accidental damage
  • Dust protection: Regular gentle dusting with soft cloths prevents buildup

Insurance and Documentation

  • Inventory records: Maintain detailed records of your collection including photos
  • Appraisals: Get valuable bottles professionally appraised
  • Insurance riders: Consider specific insurance coverage for high-value collections

Proper care is particularly important for sealed bottles, as maintaining the original contents in good condition can significantly increase value over time.

Common Questions About Old Crow Whiskey Bottle Values

Are old alcohol bottles worth anything? 
Yes, vintage alcohol bottles can be quite valuable to collectors. For Old Crow specifically, empty bottles from interesting eras can sell for $20-$100, while sealed vintage bottles can command $150-$450 depending on age and condition. Specialty decanters, like those from the Chess Series, can be worth significantly more, with some rare pieces selling for thousands of dollars.

The value is determined by age, rarity, condition, and historical significance. Pre-Prohibition bottles are particularly valuable regardless of brand.

How can I tell how old my Old Crow whiskey bottle is? 
You can determine the age of your Old Crow bottle by examining several features:

    

  1. Look for date codes on the bottom of the bottle, often appearing as two-digit numbers representing the year of manufacture
    2. 

  2. Check tax stamps for series dates (though these indicate when the stamp design was issued, not necessarily bottling date)
    3. 

  3. Examine the label design and bottle shape, which changed over different eras
    4. 

  4. Note the volume measurement (4/5 quart vs. 750ml)
    5. 

  5. Look for the distillery information - bottles produced before 1987 were made by National Distillers, while later bottles were produced by Jim Beam
    6. 



The combination of these factors can help narrow down the production period to within a few years.

Who drank Old Crow whiskey historically? 
Old Crow whiskey has a distinguished history of notable consumers. It was reportedly served in the presidential homes of Andrew Jackson, William Henry Harrison, and Ulysses S. Grant. The whiskey was also favored by numerous literary figures including Walt Whitman, Henry Clay, Mark Twain, and Jack London.

This prestigious clientele helped establish Old Crow’s reputation as a quality bourbon during America’s formative years and contributes to its historical significance for collectors today.

Who currently owns the Old Crow whiskey brand? 
Old Crow whiskey is currently owned by Jim Beam Distilling Company, which is part of Beam Suntory. Jim Beam acquired the brand in 1987 when they purchased the National Distillers portfolio. 

This acquisition marks an important dividing line for collectors, as many bourbon enthusiasts note a change in the whiskey’s formula and production methods after the Jim Beam takeover. Pre-1987 bottles from the National Distillers era are generally more sought after by collectors and typically command higher prices than those produced after the acquisition.

What is the value of a sealed Old Crow bottle from the 1960s? 
A sealed Old Crow bourbon bottle from the 1960s typically values between $140-$225 on today's collector market. The standard 86 proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey in a 4/5 quart bottle from this era is relatively common but still desirable.

Factors that can push the value toward the higher end of this range include:


    

  • Original tax stamp intact
    • 

  • Excellent label condition with minimal fading or damage
    • 

  • Good fill level (above the shoulder of the bottle)
    • 

  • No seepage or evaporation
    • 



Particularly rare variants or special bottlings from this era could potentially exceed this value range. For example, a 1960s bottle in unopened, excellent condition was valued by appraisal experts at $250-$450.

Are Old Crow chess piece decanters valuable? 
Old Crow chess piece decanters are among the most valuable whiskey collectibles on the market. Individual pieces typically range from $90-$300 for common pieces in good condition, but rare pieces can command significantly higher prices.

The 1969 Castle decanter with its original hang tag is particularly valuable, with recent listings exceeding $8,000. Complete sets of chess pieces in excellent condition can sell for $2,000-$10,000 depending on condition and whether they include original packaging.


The value of these decanters has consistently increased over time as the limited supply meets continued collector demand. Condition is crucial, with intact figurines free of chips or cracks worth substantially more than damaged examples.

<h2 class="section-header__title"> 
<span>Conclusion: Investment Potential of Old Crow Collectibles</span>

</h2>

<div class="section-header__body">As with many vintage spirits, Old Crow whiskey bottles represent both a connection to bourbon history and a potentially valuable collectible.</div>

The market for vintage whiskey bottles continues to grow as bourbon’s popularity increases worldwide. Old Crow’s historical significance, particularly bottles from the National Distillers era (pre-1987), positions these items as potentially sound investments with several advantages:

  1. Stable appreciation: Unlike many collectibles, vintage bourbon bottles have shown consistent price increases over time
  2. Limited supply: The number of surviving bottles, especially in good condition, decreases annually
  3. Growing interest: Rising international interest in American whiskey history has expanded the collector base

However, as with any collectible investment, condition remains paramount. Bottles with intact seals, clear tax stamps, undamaged labels, and proper storage history will always command the highest prices.

Whether you’re a dedicated bourbon historian, a casual collector, or simply curious about that old bottle in your cabinet, understanding Old Crow’s rich heritage and the factors that determine its value can help you appreciate these historical artifacts and make informed decisions about buying, selling, or preserving them.

External Resources for Old Crow Collectors

Category Price Notes
Modern Standard Bottles (post-1987) $10-$25 Current retail value for consumption
Empty Vintage Bottles (1960s-1980s) $20-$95 Depending on condition and label quality
Sealed 1960s-1970s Bottles $140-$225 86 proof, 4/5 quart bottles in good condition
Pre-1960s Sealed Bottles $250-$450+ Excellent condition with intact seals
Old Crow Ceramic Decanters $65-$150 Standard decorative decanters in good condition
Chess Piece Decanters (Common Pieces) $90-$300 Individual pieces from the collectible chess set
Chess Piece Decanters (Rare Pieces) $500-$8,000+ Rare pieces like the 1969 Castle with hang tag
Complete Chess Set Collections $2,000-$10,000+ Full sets in excellent condition with original packaging