Mrs. Butterworth Bottle Values: Complete Guide to Vintage Syrup Bottle Collection

Introduction to Mrs. Butterworth Bottle Collecting

The iconic Mrs. Butterworth syrup bottle has become a beloved collectible for many enthusiasts of Americana and vintage kitchen items. These distinctive matronly-shaped bottles have adorned breakfast tables since 1961, creating generations of nostalgic memories. As with many vintage kitchen items, the value of Mrs. Butterworth bottles varies widely based on age, condition, and rarity.

This comprehensive guide will help you identify valuable vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles, understand what makes certain versions more collectible, and determine the current market values for these nostalgic pieces of Americana.

Mrs. Butterworth’s syrup was introduced in 1961 by the Pinnacle Foods Group. The product’s most distinctive feature was its container - an anthropomorphic bottle shaped like a grandmotherly woman, complete with a head, torso, and base designed to look like a skirt. These original glass bottles quickly became recognized for their unique design and the clever marketing campaign that portrayed Mrs. Butterworth as a living, talking character.

The first Mrs. Butterworth glass bottles enter the market, establishing the now-famous matronly shape and amber glass design.

Minor changes to the glass mold and label designs. Bottle sizes included 24 oz, 36 oz, and larger variants. Thatcher Glass Company was a primary manufacturer.

Final versions of glass bottles produced with updated labeling. Collectors often seek bottles from this period as they're newer but still glass.

Glass bottles begin to be phased out and replaced with plastic versions, dramatically increasing the collectibility of all glass variants.

After the racial justice movement of 2020, Conagra Brands announced a planned redesign of the Mrs. Butterworth character and packaging.

The transition from glass to plastic containers in 1999 marked a significant moment for collectors. While new plastic bottles continue to be produced, vintage glass bottles have become increasingly collectible, particularly those with original labels, caps, and in excellent condition.

Glass Color and Material

Authentic vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles are typically made of amber-colored glass. This brownish hue was consistent throughout the glass bottle era (1961-1999). Be wary of clear glass or unusual colored variants, as these may be reproductions or promotional items rather than standard production bottles.

Bottle Size Variations

Mrs. Butterworth bottles were produced in several different sizes over the years:

• Small: 12 oz and 16 oz bottles (less common)
• Medium: 24 oz bottles (standard size)
• Large: 36 oz bottles (family size)
• Extra Large: Some sources mention rare 52 oz versions

Each size has different collector demand, with the larger sizes often commanding higher prices due to their impressive display qualities.

Bottom Markings

The bottom of authentic Mrs. Butterworth bottles typically contains valuable information:

• Manufacturer marks (Thatcher Glass Company was a common producer)
• Date codes (often a 1-2 digit number indicating the year of manufacture)
• Mold numbers and plant identification codes

For example, a bottle marked with “71” on the bottom typically indicates manufacture in 1971. These markings are crucial for accurate dating.

Label Variations

The labels on Mrs. Butterworth bottles evolved over time, making them useful for dating:

• Earlier bottles (1960s-1970s) often featured more elaborate labels with detailed artwork
• 1980s-1990s bottles typically had simpler, more modern label designs
• Some special editions had promotional labels for holidays or special events

Original labels in good condition significantly increase a bottle’s value. Many collectors prefer bottles with intact original labels rather than those that have been cleaned off.

The market for vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles has seen steady growth as nostalgic kitchen collectibles have gained popularity. According to research from current market listings and expert appraisals, here’s what you can expect for different variants:

Recent Notable Sales

Some exceptional examples have sold for prices well above the average ranges:

• A 1968 36 oz bottle with pristine original label and cap sold for $195 on a specialized collector platform
• A rare promotional set from the 1970s with original box sold for over $150 on Etsy
• A bulk collection of five different-sized bottles from the 1960s-1970s sold for $225 at an online auction

According to antique experts at JustAnswer, most vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles should fetch between $30-$40 in the current market, but exceptional examples with original packaging or rare features can command significantly higher prices.

Age and Rarity

Older bottles from the early production years (1961-1969) are generally more valuable than later examples. These early bottles represent the original design concept and are increasingly difficult to find in good condition.

Complete Original Packaging

Bottles that retain their:

• Original metal or plastic cap
• Fully intact label with minimal damage
• Any original box or packaging
• Promotional materials or coupons

are significantly more valuable than bottles missing these elements. A complete package can double or even triple the value compared to just the glass bottle alone.

Condition Factors

The condition has an enormous impact on value:

• No chips, cracks, or repair attempts
• Clean interior without staining or residue
• Label condition (intact, not torn or water damaged)
• Clarity of the glass (no clouding or etching)

Special Editions and Promotional Versions

Throughout its history, the Mrs. Butterworth brand released special editions that now command premium prices:

• Holiday-themed bottles
• Promotional tie-ins with other products
• Commemorative editions
• Limited regional releases

These special editions are often the most valuable in the current collector market, sometimes fetching prices well above $100 when complete with all original components.

Size and Version Variants

While all sizes can be collectible, the larger 36 oz family-size bottles often command higher prices due to their impressive display qualities and relative scarcity compared to the more common 24 oz size. The extremely rare 52 oz versions can be particularly valuable to serious collectors.

Based on current market activity and collector preferences, here are the best places to sell vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles:

1. eBay: The most active marketplace for Mrs. Butterworth bottles with numerous listings ranging from $15 to over $150 depending on age, condition, and size. eBay’s reach makes it ideal for selling more valuable specimens.

2. Etsy: An excellent platform for vintage kitchen collectibles, with Mrs. Butterworth bottles regularly listing for $20-150. Etsy tends to attract buyers willing to pay premium prices for quality collectibles.

3. Specialty Antique Sites: Platforms like Ruby Lane cater to more serious collectors and can be good venues for rarer bottles or those in exceptional condition.

4. Poshmark: While primarily a fashion site, Poshmark has expanded to include vintage collectibles, with Mrs. Butterworth bottles selling for $20-30.

5. Antique Shows and Flea Markets: In-person venues can be effective, particularly for selling to collectors who appreciate being able to inspect items directly.

6. Collector Forums and Groups: Specialized collector communities can provide direct access to the most interested buyers.

For the best results, provide clear photographs of your bottle from multiple angles, showing the bottom markings, label condition, and any identifying characteristics. Accurate dating information will also help attract serious collectors willing to pay premium prices.

Focus Areas for New Collectors

1. Start with a Specific Era: Consider focusing on a particular decade (1960s, 1970s, etc.) to build a representative collection without becoming overwhelmed.

2. Condition Priorities: Decide whether original labels and caps are important to your collection goals, as these significantly affect pricing.

3. Size Variations: Some collectors focus on acquiring all the different size variations rather than collecting across time periods.

4. Display Considerations: Think about how you’ll display your collection. The amber glass can be particularly attractive when displayed with proper lighting.

Authentication and Preservation

1. Cleaning Techniques: Use only mild soap and warm water for cleaning glass bottles. Avoid harsh chemicals that could damage labels or the glass surface.

2. Storage Recommendations: Store bottles upright in a temperature-controlled environment away from direct sunlight, which can fade labels and potentially damage the glass over time.

3. Handling Tips: Always handle vintage bottles by their base rather than by the neck or cap to prevent accidental damage.

4. Documentation: Keep records of when and where you acquired each bottle, along with any provenance information that might enhance its value.

Collection Growth Strategy

As your collection grows, consider:

1. Networking with Other Collectors: Join online forums and collector groups to learn about rare finds and upcoming opportunities.

2. Attend Antique Shows: These events often have vendors specializing in vintage kitchen items who might have rare Mrs. Butterworth bottles.

3. Set Alerts on Auction Sites: Create saved searches on platforms like eBay to be notified when new listings matching your criteria appear.

4. Consider Companion Collections: Some collectors expand their interests to include other figural syrup bottles like Aunt Jemima, creating themed kitchen collectible displays.

Browse current listings and completed sales to gauge market values and see what's currently available for purchase.

Explore handpicked vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles from collectors and dealers specializing in nostalgic kitchen items.

Join discussions with experienced bottle collectors who share expertise on dating and valuing Mrs. Butterworth bottles.

Learn about the complete history of the Mrs. Butterworth brand, including important dates and company ownership changes.

Expert appraisal services for getting professional opinions on the value of your vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles.

Watch educational videos about vintage syrup bottles including Mrs. Butterworth and Aunt Jemima collector information.

Mrs. Butterworth syrup bottles were first introduced in 1961. The iconic bottles were originally made of amber glass and shaped like a matronly woman figure. Glass bottles were produced from 1961 until 1999, when they began to be phased out in favor of plastic containers. The glass bottles from the 1960s through the late 1990s are considered vintage collectibles today.

You can determine the age of a Mrs. Butterworth bottle by checking:

1. Bottom markings: Look for date codes (often 1-2 digits indicating the year)
2. Manufacturer marks: Different glass companies made the bottles over the years
3. Label design: Labels evolved significantly from the 1960s through 1990s
4. Cap type: Earlier bottles had metal caps, later ones had plastic
5. Bottle size and mold details: Subtle changes occurred over the production years

The most reliable dating method is checking the bottom markings, where you may find numbers like "71" indicating manufacture in 1971.

The average value of a vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottle typically ranges from $15 to $60, depending on age, condition, and completeness. Bottles from the 1960s tend to command higher prices ($35-$65), while those from the 1970s-1990s generally sell for $15-$40. Rare variants, promotional editions, or bottles in mint condition with original caps and labels can sell for $75-$200 or more. Plastic bottles made after 1999 have minimal collector value, usually under $15.

Yes, Mrs. Butterworth bottles are worth collecting for several reasons:

1. They represent iconic Americana and kitchen nostalgia
2. The glass versions are no longer produced, making them increasingly scarce
3. They have a distinctive figural design that appeals to collectors
4. They're relatively affordable compared to many other collectibles
5. They have shown steady appreciation in value over time

Their cultural significance and the fact that complete collections can be displayed attractively make them popular among collectors of advertising memorabilia and vintage kitchen items.

Aunt Jemima syrup bottles typically have slightly lower values than Mrs. Butterworth bottles in the current market. Vintage Aunt Jemima glass syrup bottles generally sell for $10-$20 each, with sets of three bottles valued at approximately $10-$20 total according to expert appraisals. By comparison, Mrs. Butterworth bottles from similar time periods often sell for $15-$40 each. The higher value for Mrs. Butterworth bottles is likely due to their more distinctive figural design and the fact that they've been discontinued in glass form.

When purchasing vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles, look for:

1. No chips, cracks, or repairs to the glass
2. Original labels in good condition (not reproductions)
3. Original caps (metal for older bottles, plastic for newer ones)
4. Clear bottom markings to verify authenticity and age
5. Clean interiors without stubborn staining or residue
6. Any original packaging or promotional materials

Be cautious of bottles with replaced labels or those that have been heavily cleaned, as these modifications can significantly reduce collector value.

Mrs. Butterworth bottles began transitioning from glass to plastic in 1999. This change marked the end of the glass bottle era that had started with the product's introduction in 1961. The transition wasn't immediate, and some glass bottles were still available in certain markets into the early 2000s, but plastic gradually became the standard. This transition point is significant for collectors, as it makes all glass Mrs. Butterworth bottles finite in number and increasingly collectible.

The best platforms for selling vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles include:

1. eBay - Largest audience of collectors and highest number of sales
2. Etsy - Good for higher-end specimens with premium pricing
3. Ruby Lane - Targets serious antique collectors
4. Poshmark - Growing marketplace for vintage items
5. Facebook Marketplace - Good for local sales to avoid shipping
6. Antique shows and flea markets - Best for networking with serious collectors

eBay typically offers the most liquidity and competitive pricing, making it the top choice for most sellers of vintage Mrs. Butterworth bottles.

Conclusion: The Future of Mrs. Butterworth Bottle Collecting

As with many pieces of Americana, the value of Mrs. Butterworth bottles combines nostalgia, history, and scarcity. With the complete transition to plastic bottles after 1999, the pool of vintage glass bottles is permanently fixed, suggesting potential for continued appreciation in value over time.

The recent announcements about brand redesigns following cultural conversations in 2020 may further increase interest in these vintage items as representations of American advertising history. For collectors, this makes now an interesting time to begin or expand a collection of these iconic kitchen collectibles.

Whether you’re a serious collector, a casual enthusiast, or simply curious about the value of an old bottle found in a family kitchen, understanding the factors that determine Mrs. Butterworth bottle values can help you make informed decisions about buying, selling, or preserving these charming pieces of Americana.