Antique Silverware Value Guide: What Your Old Silver is Worth in 2024
Discover the true value of your old silverware - from identifying sterling silver to finding the most valuable brands - plus expert tips for selling antique flatware.
By Appraisily TeamLast updated September 26, 2024
Finding a set of old silverware in your attic or inheriting your grandmother’s precious silver flatware set might leave you wondering: what is my old silverware really worth? Antique silver pieces can vary dramatically in value, from simple sterling spoons worth their weight in silver to rare patterns from prestigious makers that command thousands of dollars.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know about determining old silverware value, from identifying authentic sterling pieces to understanding which brands and patterns are most sought after by collectors.
<div class="section-header__body">The value of old silverware depends on multiple factors that go beyond just the silver content. Understanding these elements is crucial for proper valuation.</div>
Antique silver flatware can range dramatically in price. According to experts at Antique Silver, pieces can be worth as little as $5 for common items or as much as $1 million for exceptionally rare examples. Most household sterling silver flatware falls somewhere in between, typically valued between $20-100 per piece depending on several key factors.
Let’s examine the primary determinants of value:
Key Value Factors for Antique Silverware
1. Silver Content and Purity
The most fundamental value factor is whether your pieces are sterling silver, silver plate, or another material entirely:
Sterling Silver: Contains 92.5% pure silver and 7.5% copper or other metals. Sterling silver flatware is typically worth $20-30+ per piece at minimum for the silver content alone.
Silver Plate: A thin coating of silver over a base metal. Generally has minimal value ($5-15 per piece) unless it’s a rare pattern or maker.
Coin Silver: Older American silver (90% pure) made before sterling standardization. Often valuable for its historical significance.
Other Metals: Sometimes confused with silver, items made of stainless steel, aluminum, or nickel silver have minimal collector value.
According to Bellevue Rare Coins, individual pieces of sterling silverware may be worth $5-$30+ each, though particularly desirable pieces can command much higher prices.
2. Maker and Brand Prestige
Some silverware manufacturers are significantly more valuable than others:
Value by Prestigious Maker
Average price ranges per piece for sterling silver flatware
Category
Price
Notes
Georg Jensen
$100-$1,000+
Danish designer with distinct modernist style
Tiffany & Co.
$75-$500+
Premium for older patterns like Chrysanthemum
Gorham
$50-$300+
Especially Chantilly, Buttercup patterns
Reed & Barton
$40-$250+
Francis I pattern commands premium
International Silver
$25-$150+
Common but still valuable for sterling
</tbody>
</table>
According to Samuelson’s Diamonds, premium silverware brands can range from $35 to millions depending on rarity and condition.
3. Pattern Rarity and Popularity
Certain patterns are highly sought after by collectors, particularly:
Discontinued patterns from major manufacturers
Limited edition or commemorative designs
Patterns with detailed hand-engraving or art nouveau styling
Very old patterns showing excellent craftsmanship
Collectors tend to pay premiums for complete sets in popular patterns. The Decorative Collective notes that matching sets of antique silver flatware are particularly valuable in today’s market.
4. Age and Historical Significance
Silverware Historical Periods and Values
1700s
Colonial/Georgian Silver
American colonial and Georgian period silver pieces are extremely valuable due to scarcity and historical importance. Pieces from this era often sell for thousands, regardless of maker.
1800-1870
Victorian Silver
Victorian-era silver typically features ornate designs with floral motifs. These pieces command premium prices, especially those from renowned British silversmiths.
1880-1920
Art Nouveau Period
Distinctive curving lines and natural forms characterize this era. Pieces by designers like Georg Jensen from this period are highly collectible and valuable.
1920-1950
Art Deco Period
Geometric patterns and streamlined designs. These pieces have seen increasing collector interest in recent years, raising their values.
1950-Present
Modern Silver
Contemporary silver designs are typically valued closer to their silver content, though designer pieces can still command premiums.
5. Condition
The condition significantly impacts value:
Mint/Excellent: Original finish with minimal wear. May still have original boxes or packaging. Commands highest prices.
Very Good: Minor wear from normal use, but no dents or repairs.
Good: Shows typical signs of use, may have minor dents or some wear to patterns.
Fair/Poor: Significant damage, repairs, or plate wear. Often worth only melt value for sterling pieces.
As noted on Reddit discussions, condition can make the difference between scrap value and significant collector interest.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>How to Identify Valuable Sterling Silver Flatware</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Before determining value, you must first confirm whether your silverware is actually sterling silver or merely silver-plated.</div>
Look for Markings and Hallmarks
The most reliable way to identify sterling silver is to check for maker’s marks and hallmarks stamped on the back of pieces:
“Sterling”: The word “Sterling” indicates 92.5% silver content (American standard).
“925”: Numerical designation for sterling silver purity.
“EPNS”: Stands for “Electroplated Nickel Silver” - indicates silver plate, not solid silver.
“Silver plate” or “EP”: Indicates plated items with minimal silver content.
Maker’s Marks: Look for manufacturer stamps like a lion (British sterling), or company names like “Gorham,” “Reed & Barton,” etc.
According to Bellamy’s World, examining these hallmarks is the crucial first step in valuation.
Sterling Silver Identification Checklist
Use this checklist to determine if your silverware is sterling silver
Item is marked 'Sterling' or '925'
Piece has visible hallmarks or maker's marks
NOT marked 'EPNS' or 'Silver Plate'
Has a substantial weight (heavier than stainless steel)
Develops tarnish (sterling tarnishes, plate typically doesn't)
Makes a distinct 'ping' sound when tapped (not a dull sound)
Magnetism test - sterling is not magnetic
Testing Methods for Unmarked Pieces
If your silverware lacks clear markings, there are several ways to test for silver content:
Magnet Test: Sterling silver is not magnetic. If a magnet sticks to your piece, it’s likely not sterling.
Ice Test: Silver conducts heat extremely well. Place an ice cube on the piece - sterling silver will conduct cold quickly.
Acid Test: Silver testing kits with nitric acid are available and can determine silver content.
Professional Testing: For valuable but unmarked pieces, consider professional testing through a jeweler or appraiser.
Common Valuable Silverware Patterns
Certain patterns consistently maintain higher values:
Notable Valuable Silver Flatware Patterns
Patterns that command premium prices
Category
Price
Notes
Gorham Chantilly
$50-300 per piece
Elegant floral pattern, highly collectible
Tiffany Chrysanthemum
$100-500+ per piece
Ornate floral design, premium for serving pieces
Georg Jensen Acorn
$150-600+ per piece
Distinctive Danish modernist design
Reed & Barton Francis I
$75-350+ per piece
Detailed fruit and flower pattern
Towle Old Master
$40-200 per piece
Renaissance-inspired design
</tbody>
</table>
When examining these patterns, look for consistent detailing throughout the entire piece. Premium examples will have crisp, clear pattern work even after decades of use.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Calculating Silver Value by Weight</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">For sterling silver flatware that may not have significant collector value, understanding the scrap or melt value is important.</div>
One way to establish a minimum value for sterling silver flatware is to calculate its worth based on the current silver spot price. This is particularly relevant for damaged pieces or very common patterns that don’t command collector premiums.
How to Calculate Melt Value
Weigh your sterling silver pieces in grams or troy ounces
Multiply by 0.925 (sterling silver is 92.5% pure silver)
Multiply by the current silver spot price (changes daily)
Subtract dealer discount (typically 20-30% off spot price)
For example, if you have a sterling silver spoon weighing 30 grams with silver spot price at $30/troy ounce:
This gives you a baseline value, but remember that collectible or well-preserved pieces are often worth significantly more than their melt value.
According to a Reddit discussion, even common sterling silver pieces should never be scrapped for melt value without first checking for collector interest.
Various antique silver pattern examples showing different design elements and makers' styles
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Most Valuable Silverware Brands</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Certain silverware manufacturers consistently command higher prices due to their craftsmanship, historical significance, and collector demand.</div>
According to Samuelson’s Diamonds, these brands stand out for their exceptional value:
1. Georg Jensen
Danish designer Georg Jensen is renowned for distinctive, modernist designs that have become incredibly collectible. Jensen silverware regularly sells for multiples of its silver content value. Certain patterns like Acorn (Konge) and Pyramid command the highest prices.
2. Tiffany & Co.
Tiffany silver flatware represents American luxury craftsmanship at its finest. Patterns like Chrysanthemum, English King, and Wave Edge are highly sought after. Complete sets in original boxes can sell for tens of thousands of dollars at auction.
3. Gorham
America’s oldest major silver manufacturer, Gorham has produced countless patterns, but certain designs like Chantilly, Buttercup, and Strasbourg maintain particular value. Gorham’s Martele line, featuring hand-hammered designs, ranks among the most valuable American silverware ever produced.
4. Reed & Barton
Known for highly detailed, nature-inspired patterns, Reed & Barton’s Francis I pattern is one of the most valuable in today’s market. Their silver is known for substantial weight and excellent craftsmanship.
5. Wallace
The Wallace company created the popular Grand Baroque pattern, known for its ornate scrollwork. Sir Christopher and Rose Point patterns also maintain strong collector demand.
6. Towle
Towle’s Old Master pattern is particularly valuable, but their King Richard and French Provincial designs also command strong prices in the resale market.
According to a thread on Reddit, while common International Silver pieces might only fetch scrap value, rare Georg Jensen or Gorham Martele pieces could be worth “low five figures or more.”
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Complete Sets vs. Individual Pieces</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">The marketplace values complete sets differently than individual pieces, affecting what you might expect to receive when selling.</div>
Value Premium for Complete Sets
Complete sterling silver flatware sets typically command a premium over individual pieces, especially when they include:
Original storage chest or canteen
Complete place settings (usually 8 or 12)
Matching serving pieces
Consistent condition throughout
Original documentation or receipts
According to NOLA.com, a complete service for 12 in Towle El Grandee sterling pattern might retail for around $14,000 new, but typically resells for considerably less.
Most Valuable Serving Pieces
Certain individual serving pieces consistently command higher prices than standard place setting items:
Value of Specialty Silverware Pieces
Price ranges for uncommon serving pieces in sterling silver
Category
Price
Notes
Fish Serving Set
$200-700
Specialty knife and fork for serving fish
Berry Spoon
$150-400
Large ornate spoon with decorative bowl
Asparagus Server
$200-600
Specialized tong-like serving piece
Bon Bon Spoon
$100-300
Decorative small serving spoon
Ice Cream Slice
$150-400
Specialized server with unique shape
</tbody>
</table>
Rarer serving pieces like asparagus servers, sardine forks, and game carving sets often sell for significantly more than common pieces like tablespoons or teaspoons due to their scarcity and specialized nature.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Where to Sell Antique Silverware</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">Knowing the best venues to sell your old silverware can significantly impact the price you receive.</div>
Best Places to Sell Valuable Silverware
Different selling venues offer various advantages and drawbacks:
Auction Houses: Best for rare or high-end pieces. Houses like Christie’s, Sotheby’s, or Bonhams specialize in premium antique silver.
Pros: Reach serious collectors, expert cataloging
Cons: High commissions (20-25%), minimum value requirements
Antique Dealers: Good for quick sales of quality pieces.
Pros: Immediate payment, no listing/waiting
Cons: Typically pay 40-60% of retail value
eBay: Good for common to mid-range pieces with established patterns.
Pros: Broad audience, competitive bidding
Cons: Fees, shipping challenges, potential for disputes
Specialty Online Marketplaces: Sites like Replacements.com buy and sell pattern-matched silverware.
Pros: Expertise in matching patterns, fair offers
Cons: May only want certain patterns or pieces
Local Consignment Shops: Good for mid-range pieces with regional appeal.
Pros: Low effort, local market knowledge
Cons: Higher commissions, slower sales
Silver Buyers/Refiners: Good for damaged pieces or very common patterns.
Pros: Immediate payment, no condition concerns
Cons: Only pay melt value (typically lowest return)
According to Bellamy’s World, seeking the expertise of an accredited appraiser before selling can help ensure you receive fair value for your sterling silver, especially for antique pieces.
Getting Your Silverware Appraised
Before selling valuable antique silverware, consider professional appraisal:
Find an accredited appraiser through organizations like the International Society of Appraisers or American Society of Appraisers
Expect to pay $100-300 for a written appraisal (avoid percentage-based fees)
Get replacement value and fair market value assessments
Request specific details about maker, pattern, age, and condition notes
Professional appraisals provide documentation for insurance, potential tax deductions for donations, and stronger negotiating positions when selling.
<h2 class="section-header__title">
<span>Tips for Collecting Valuable Silverware</span>
</h2>
<div class="section-header__body">For those interested in building a collection, understanding what to look for can help identify valuable pieces.</div>
What to Look For When Collecting
Focus on quality over quantity: A few excellent pieces are better than many mediocre ones
Learn to identify important makers: Study hallmarks and maker’s marks
Condition matters: Avoid pieces with dents, repairs, or excessive wear
Research pattern popularity: Some patterns maintain value better than others
Look for unusual pieces: Rare serving pieces often appreciate faster than common tableware
Watch for bargains: Estate sales, thrift stores, and online auctions occasionally offer underpriced sterling
Current Market Trends
According to data from various sources including eBay, the market for antique silverware has evolved:
Shifting tastes: Formal dining has declined, reducing demand for complete sets
Material value increase: Rising silver prices have increased the floor value of sterling pieces
Designer emphasis: Mid-century modern and Art Deco pieces seeing increased collector interest
Serving piece premiums: Unusual serving pieces commanding higher prices than place settings
Condition importance: Pristine condition increasingly important as supply of quality pieces decreases
The LoveToKnow article explains that understanding these market trends is crucial when determining appropriate values for antique silver.
Frequently Asked Questions About Old Silverware Value
How can I tell if my silverware is valuable?
To determine if your silverware is valuable, first check for sterling silver markings like "Sterling" or "925." Then identify the maker and pattern using hallmarks on the back of pieces. Complete sets in good condition from prestigious makers like Tiffany, Georg Jensen, or Gorham are typically most valuable. Rare patterns or unusual serving pieces often command premiums above their silver content value.
What is the scrap value of sterling silver flatware?
The scrap value of sterling silver flatware fluctuates with the current silver spot price. To calculate approximate scrap value:
Weigh your pieces in grams
Multiply by 0.925 (since sterling is 92.5% silver)
Convert to troy ounces (divide by 31.1)
Multiply by the current silver spot price
However, most sterling flatware is worth more than its scrap value when sold to collectors or dealers unless it’s damaged or an extremely common pattern.
Is vintage silver-plated flatware worth anything?
Vintage silver-plated flatware typically has minimal value compared to sterling silver, as it contains only a thin layer of silver over a base metal. Most silver plate sells for $1-15 per piece depending on condition and design. However, certain exceptions exist:
Silver plate from prestigious makers like Christofle or WMF
Ornate Victorian-era pieces with excellent detailing
Art Deco or mid-century modern designs with collector appeal
Complete sets in original boxes or chests
Silver plate has primarily decorative rather than intrinsic material value.
What are the most valuable silverware patterns?
The most valuable silverware patterns include:
Tiffany & Co.: Chrysanthemum, English King, and Wave Edge
Georg Jensen: Acorn (Konge), Pyramid, and Blossom
Gorham: Martele, Chantilly, and Buttercup
Reed & Barton: Francis I and Love Disarmed
Wallace: Grand Baroque and Sir Christopher
Towle: Old Master and El Grandee
Value depends not just on pattern but also on condition, age, and completeness of the set.
Where should I get my sterling silver flatware appraised?
For professional appraisals of sterling silver flatware, consider:
Certified appraisers through the International Society of Appraisers or American Society of Appraisers
Auction houses like Sotheby’s, Christie’s, or Bonhams for valuable pieces
Reputable antique dealers specializing in silver
Silver specialists at major department stores (for newer patterns)
Avoid appraisers who charge a percentage of the item’s value, as this creates a conflict of interest. Expect to pay a flat fee of $100-300 for a written appraisal.
How much is a silver spoon worth in scrap?
A typical sterling silver teaspoon weighs about 20-30 grams (0.65-0.96 troy ounces). At a silver price of $30 per troy ounce:
A 25g spoon contains approximately 0.74 troy ounces of metal
At 92.5% purity, that’s 0.68 troy ounces of pure silver
Worth approximately $20.40 in silver content
Typical dealer payout would be 70-80% of this value, or $14-16
However, selling for scrap should be a last resort, as most sterling silver spoons are worth more to collectors than as scrap metal.
Does old silverware have any value without markings?
Unmarked silverware can still have value, but it's harder to determine. Consider these steps:
Test for silver content using acid testing kits or the magnet test
Consult an expert who can identify patterns visually
Look for design characteristics that match known manufacturers
Weigh the pieces to estimate potential silver content
Even without markings, pieces with exceptional craftsmanship, unusual designs, or antique age can have collector value. At minimum, if testing confirms the piece is sterling silver, it will have value based on its silver content.
What is a complete sterling silver flatware service worth?
A complete sterling silver flatware service varies widely in value based on maker, pattern, and condition. For reference:
Basic 8-piece service from mid-tier maker: $500-2,000
Complete 12-piece service by Gorham or Reed & Barton: $2,000-5,000
Deluxe Tiffany or Jensen service with all serving pieces: $5,000-20,000+
Rare patterns or antique complete services: $10,000-50,000+
Complete sets with original storage chests generally command a premium of 20-30% over the same pieces sold individually.
The value of old silverware varies dramatically based on its silver content, maker, pattern, age, and condition. While some pieces may be worth only their weight in silver, others can command thousands of dollars from collectors eager to acquire rare patterns or complete services.
Before selling inherited or found silver flatware, take time to properly identify what you have. Check for hallmarks, research patterns, and consider professional appraisal for potentially valuable pieces. Remember that complete sets typically command higher prices than individual pieces, and certain manufacturers like Georg Jensen, Tiffany, and Gorham consistently outperform others in the resale market.
Whether you’re looking to sell a family heirloom or start collecting antique silverware yourself, understanding these value factors will help ensure you make informed decisions about your sterling silver treasures.
