| ValueMyStuff |
$28-35 per item |
24-48 hours |
Former Sotheby's and Christie's experts, 60+ categories |
| Mearto |
$19-69 per item |
24-48 hours |
Direct connection to auction houses, authentication certificates available |
| Mr. Expert |
€5-20 per item |
48 hours |
European specialists, multilingual service |
| Heritage Auctions |
Free |
Varies |
Auction estimate only, focused on items for potential consignment |
| Dr. Lori V |
$30-40 per item |
Varies |
Includes actual sales records and selling price evidence |
</tbody>
</table>
Heritage Auctions
Heritage Auctions offers free online appraisals for collectibles being considered for auction. Their service is particularly valuable if you’re potentially interested in selling your items, as their experts evaluate items specifically for auction inclusion and provide estimated values based on their extensive auction market knowledge.
ValueMyStuff
ValueMyStuff employs over 60 experts who formerly worked at prestigious auction houses like Sotheby’s and Christie’s. They provide appraisals within 24-48 hours starting at $28 per item. Their service covers over 60 categories of collectibles, making them one of the most comprehensive options available.
Mearto
Mearto specializes in antique appraisals with a quick 24-48 hour turnaround time. They offer a direct connection to auction houses for items you might want to sell and provide authentication certificates for verified items.
Dr. Lori V
Dr. Lori V provides detailed online appraisals that include actual sales records with selling prices, showing you where similar objects have sold. This approach provides valuable market context beyond a simple valuation.
Mr. Expert
Mr. Expert offers appraisals within 48 hours for items of artistic value, furniture, and collectibles. Based in Europe, they provide multilingual services and specialize in European antiques and collectibles.
Photography Guidelines
-
Use good lighting: Natural, indirect daylight works best. Avoid harsh shadows and glare.
-
Capture multiple angles: Take photos from all sides, top, bottom, and any areas with distinctive features.
-
Include close-ups of marks and signatures: These details are crucial for authentication.
-
Show scale: Include a ruler or common object for size reference.
-
Document condition issues: Clearly photograph any damage, repairs, or wear.
-
Maintain a neutral background: Use a plain, contrasting background that doesn’t distract from the item.
-
Ensure clear focus: Blurry images make accurate appraisal difficult or impossible.
Beyond photographs, providing comprehensive information helps appraisers make accurate assessments:
-
Dimensions: Precise measurements of height, width, depth, and diameter.
-
Material composition: Note all materials used in the item’s construction.
-
Markings and signatures: Transcribe any text, signatures, or markings exactly as they appear.
-
Provenance: Include any known history, previous owners, or documentation.
-
Condition details: Note any repairs, damage, alterations, or restoration work.
-
Age estimate: If you have information about when the item was made or acquired.
-
Additional context: Any other details that might be relevant to the item’s value.
Consider these factors when selecting an online appraisal service:
1. Purpose of Appraisal
Different purposes require different types of appraisals:
- Curiosity/General Knowledge: Basic valuation services are sufficient
- Insurance Coverage: Look for services offering formal appraisals accepted by insurance companies
- Estate Planning/Tax Purposes: Requires certified appraisers who can provide legally binding documents
- Potential Sale: Services connected to auction houses or marketplaces may be most helpful
2. Appraiser Credentials
Verify the qualifications of the appraisers:
- Professional Background: Look for experts with auction house experience (Christie’s, Sotheby’s) or museum backgrounds
- Specialization: Ensure the service has specialists in your specific item category
- Certification: For formal appraisals, check for certifications from organizations like the International Society of Appraisers (ISA) or American Society of Appraisers (ASA)
3. Reputation and Reviews
Research each service thoroughly:
- Read customer reviews and testimonials
- Check Better Business Bureau ratings
- Look for press coverage and mentions in reputable publications
- Ask for recommendations in collector forums or groups
4. Report Detail Level
Different services provide varying levels of detail:
- Basic Valuation: Simple estimated value range
- Detailed Appraisal: Includes authentication analysis, condition assessment, and market comparables
- Formal Documentation: Comprehensive reports suitable for insurance, tax, or legal purposes
5. Cost vs. Value
Balance cost considerations with your needs:
- Free services typically provide basic estimates only
- Mid-range services ($20-50) offer more detailed analysis from qualified experts
- Premium services ($75+) provide comprehensive documentation and certification
According to a Consumer Reports investigation, online valuations can provide legitimate estimates when conducted by qualified professionals. These services offer valuations, not authentications, and their accuracy depends largely on the quality of information provided and the expertise of the appraiser.
When Online Appraisals Are Most Reliable
Online appraisals tend to be most accurate for:
- Common collectibles with established market values
- Items with clear markings or signatures that can be photographed
- Mass-produced antiques from recognized manufacturers
- Pieces with distinctive visual characteristics easily captured in photos
When In-Person Appraisals May Be Necessary
Consider in-person appraisals for:
- Very high-value items (typically over $10,000)
- Potentially rare or exceptional pieces
- Items where authenticity is in question
- Appraisals needed for legal proceedings, tax purposes, or major insurance claims
As noted by Martha Stewart’s antiques experts, “In addition to online services and search engines, it is possible to find out how much your antiques are worth by simply asking an antique dealer or an appraiser at an auction house, for instance.” This multi-faceted approach often provides the most comprehensive understanding of an item’s value.
Emerging Technologies
Several technologies are transforming online appraisals:
-
Artificial Intelligence: Some platforms now use AI to assist with initial categorization and identification, though human experts still provide the final valuations.
-
Image Recognition Software: Advanced algorithms can help identify maker’s marks, patterns, and even detect signs of forgery or alteration.
-
Virtual Reality (VR): Emerging VR technologies allow appraisers to examine items in a more immersive way than static photographs.
-
Video Consultation: Live video calls enable real-time interaction between appraisers and collectors, addressing the limitations of static photos.
-
Blockchain Authentication: Some services are beginning to use blockchain technology to create immutable records of appraisals and provenance.
Mobile Applications
Several mobile apps have emerged to help with antique identification and valuation:
- Specialized antique identification apps that use image recognition technology
- Auction price database apps that track recent sales
- Collection management software with built-in valuation tools
While these technologies show promise, they currently serve as supplements to, rather than replacements for, expert human evaluation.
Online antique appraisal services typically use one of several pricing models:
Per-Item Pricing
The most common model charges a flat fee per item:
- Basic valuations: $15-30 per item
- Detailed appraisals: $30-75 per item
- Premium formal appraisals: $75-150+ per item
Many services offer discounts for multiple items submitted simultaneously.
Subscription Services
Some platforms offer subscription models:
- Monthly access to a certain number of appraisals
- Annual memberships with unlimited basic appraisals
- Tiered subscription levels for different appraisal types
Free Services with Limitations
Several services offer free valuations with specific limitations:
- Auction houses providing free estimates for potential consignments
- Limited-detail appraisals as lead generators for paid services
- Community forums where collectors share opinions (not professional appraisals)
Cost Comparison to In-Person Appraisals
According to WorthWise Appraisers, traditional in-person formal appraisals typically start at $250-350 for a single item, with additional items adding $25-100 each. This makes online appraisals significantly more affordable for most purposes.
The exact cost depends on several factors:
- Item rarity and complexity
- Type of report needed
- Turnaround time required
- Appraiser’s credentials and expertise
External Resources for Antique Appraisals
tool
Heritage Auctions Free Appraisals
Submit photos and descriptions of your collectibles for free evaluation by Heritage Auctions experts, who will determine if your items are suitable for auction and provide estimated values.
tool
ValueMyStuff Online Appraisal Service
Access expert appraisals within 24-48 hours from former Sotheby's and Christie's professionals across more than 60 categories of art, antiques, and collectibles.
tool
Mearto Antique Appraisals
Get online antique appraisals from experts within 24-48 hours, with options for authentication certificates and direct connections to auction houses for selling.
service
Dr. Lori V's Online Appraisal Form
Submit items for detailed appraisals that include actual sales records with selling prices, showing you where similar objects have sold in the marketplace.
article
Consumer Reports: How Much Is Your Stuff Worth?
Comprehensive analysis of antique appraisal options, including insights on the legitimacy and limitations of online valuation services.
article
Martha Stewart: How to Value and Sell Antiques
Expert advice on determining the value of antiques and collectibles, including both online and traditional appraisal methods.
guide
WorthWise Appraisers: What Appraisals Cost
Detailed breakdown of appraisal costs for antiques and collectibles, helping you understand pricing differences between online and in-person services.
tool
Mr. Expert Online Art and Antique Valuation
European-based service offering appraisals within 48 hours for artwork, furniture, and collectibles, with multilingual support and European specialization.
Research Before Submitting
-
Conduct preliminary research: Familiarize yourself with your item’s category and potential value range before submission.
-
Identify key features: Learn which aspects are most important for valuation in your item’s category.
-
Check completed sales: Look at online marketplaces and auction results for similar items that have recently sold.
-
Be thorough but concise: Include all relevant information without overwhelming the appraiser with unnecessary details.
-
Never omit flaws: Always disclose all condition issues, repairs, or alterations honestly.
-
Include provenance documentation: If you have certificates of authenticity, receipts, or other provenance, include clear images of these.
Photograph Strategically
-
Focus on diagnostic features: For certain items, specific details are crucial for authentication and valuation.
-
Capture true colors: Use natural lighting and adjust your camera settings to show accurate colors.
-
Show size context: Always include measurement tools or common objects for scale.
Get Multiple Opinions
-
Consider second opinions: For valuable items, submit to multiple services to compare results.
-
Consult specialist databases: Many collectible categories have specialized price guides and databases.
-
Verify unusual findings: If an appraisal seems unexpectedly high or low, seek additional opinions.
Frequently Asked Questions About Online Antique Appraisals
Are online antique appraisals legitimate?
Yes, online antique appraisals from reputable services are legitimate, but they have limitations. According to Consumer Reports, several websites offer credible estimates by professional appraisers and experts across diverse collecting categories. These services provide valuations rather than authentications, and their accuracy depends on the quality of photos and information you provide, as well as the expertise of the appraiser reviewing your submission.
For basic valuation purposes and initial estimates, online appraisals can be quite reliable. However, for extremely valuable items, items requiring authentication, or appraisals needed for legal, tax, or insurance purposes, an in-person examination by a certified appraiser may still be necessary.
Is there an app to check the value of antiques?
Yes, several apps are available to help check antique values. Antique ID is one example that helps users identify and value collectibles. These apps typically use image recognition technology combined with price databases to provide estimated values.
Other popular options include:
- Collector apps with built-in valuation tools
- Auction house apps that connect to sales databases
- Specialized category apps for coins, stamps, or specific collectibles
While these apps provide convenient initial estimates, they shouldn’t replace professional appraisals for important valuations. Most experts recommend using apps as starting points for research rather than definitive valuation tools.
How can I find out how much an antique is worth?
There are multiple approaches to determining an antique's worth:
-
Online appraisal services: Submit photos and information to professional appraisers through platforms like ValueMyStuff, Mearto, or Heritage Auctions.
-
Consult local experts: As Martha Stewart’s experts note, "It is possible to find out how much your antiques are worth by simply asking an antique dealer or an appraiser at an auction house."
-
Research completed sales: Check auction results, eBay completed listings, and specialized price guides for similar items.
-
Use collector forums: Many collecting communities have forums where members share knowledge about valuations.
-
Attend appraisal events: Many museums and antique shows host appraisal days where experts evaluate items in person.
For the most accurate assessment, combining several of these approaches is recommended, especially for potentially valuable items.
How much does it cost to get an appraisal on antiques?
Antique appraisal costs vary significantly based on the service type:
Online Appraisals:
- Basic online valuations: $15-35 per item
- More detailed online appraisals: $30-75 per item
- Premium online services: $75-150+ per item
In-Person Appraisals:
According to WorthWise Appraisers, formal in-person appraisals typically start at $250-350 for a single item. Additional items usually add incremental costs of $25-100 per item.
The exact cost depends on:
- The item’s rarity and complexity
- The appraiser’s expertise and credentials
- The type of documentation required
- Whether the appraisal needs to meet specific legal standards (for insurance, tax, or legal purposes)
Some auction houses and dealers offer free appraisals for items they might potentially purchase or sell on consignment.
Are free online antique appraisals reliable?
Free online antique appraisals can provide useful preliminary information but typically have significant limitations compared to paid professional services.
Free appraisals are most reliable when:
- Provided by established auction houses like Heritage Auctions looking for consignments
- Offered as initial consultations by qualified professionals
- Given for common items with well-established market values
They tend to be less reliable when:
- Dealing with rare, unusual, or potentially very valuable items
- Requiring detailed authentication
- Needed for official purposes like insurance or taxes
- Provided by anonymous online forums or unverified sources
Free appraisals generally provide basic value ranges rather than detailed analyses and usually don’t include formal documentation. They’re best used as starting points for further research rather than definitive valuations.
What are the best online antique appraisal services?
Several online appraisal services are highly regarded in the industry:
-
ValueMyStuff: Known for employing former Sotheby’s and Christie’s experts across 60+ categories. Appraisals start at $28 and are delivered within 24-48 hours.
-
Mearto: Offers quick turnaround (24-48 hours) with options for authentication certificates and direct connections to auction houses. Pricing starts at $19.
-
Heritage Auctions: Provides free appraisals for items being considered for auction consignment. Especially strong for collectibles, coins, and memorabilia.
-
Dr. Lori V: Delivers detailed appraisals that include actual sales records with comparable prices, providing market context. Pricing starts around $30-40.
-
Mr. Expert: European-based service with multilingual support, specializing in European antiques and art. Prices range from €5-20 per item.
The "best" service depends on your specific needs, the type of item being appraised, and whether you need a quick estimate or formal documentation.
How do I prepare my antique for online appraisal?
Proper preparation is crucial for accurate online appraisals:
Photography:
- Take multiple clear, high-resolution images from all angles
- Capture close-ups of signatures, marks, and details
- Photograph any damage or repairs
- Use natural lighting without harsh shadows
- Include a ruler or common object for scale
- Use a plain, contrasting background
Information to Include:
- Precise measurements (height, width, depth)
- Material composition
- Condition details, including any damage or repairs
- Known history or provenance
- Previous appraisals or sales receipts
- Maker’s marks or signatures, transcribed exactly as they appear
- Any questions or concerns you have about the item
The more comprehensive your submission, the more accurate the resulting appraisal will be. Remember that appraisers can only evaluate what they can see in your photographs and what you tell them about the item.
Can I get an antique appraised near me?
Yes, in-person antique appraisals are widely available across the United States. To find qualified appraisers near you:
-
Professional Organizations: Search directories from the International Society of Appraisers (ISA), American Society of Appraisers (ASA), or Appraisers Association of America (AAA).
-
Auction Houses: Local and regional auction houses often provide appraisal services, especially for items you might consider consigning.
-
Antique Dealers: Established dealers frequently offer appraisals, though be aware they may have an interest in purchasing undervalued items.
-
Appraisal Events: Museums, historical societies, and antique shows often host appraisal days where experts evaluate items for a nominal fee.
-
Estate Appraisers: Professionals who specialize in estate valuations can provide comprehensive appraisals of multiple items.
When choosing an in-person appraiser, verify their credentials, specialization in your item’s category, and whether they provide the type of appraisal document you need (insurance, fair market value, etc.).
As technology continues to advance, the gap between online and in-person appraisals continues to narrow. The integration of video consultations, artificial intelligence, and enhanced imaging capabilities is making remote valuations increasingly accurate and reliable.
For most collectors, online appraisals offer an excellent starting point—providing accessible expert opinions at reasonable costs. While they may not entirely replace traditional in-person appraisals for extremely valuable or complex items, they have democratized access to professional valuations for millions of collectors worldwide.
When approaching online appraisals, remember these key principles:
- Choose reputable services with verified experts and transparent credentials
- Provide comprehensive information and high-quality images
- Understand the limitations of remote assessment
- Consider the purpose of your appraisal when selecting a service
- Use online appraisals as part of a broader research approach for important items
By following these guidelines, you can effectively leverage online appraisal services to better understand, document, and potentially monetize your antique treasures without ever leaving home.
Whether you’re a serious collector, an inheritor of family heirlooms, or simply curious about a flea market find, online antique appraisals offer a valuable resource in your collecting journey—making expert knowledge more accessible than ever before in the history of antiques and collectibles.
