| Heritage Auctions |
Free |
Auction assessment only |
| ValueMyStuff |
$28-$40 |
Per item, based on category |
| Mearto |
$19-$69 |
Varies by report detail level |
| Dr. Lori V |
$30-$59 |
Includes sales data records |
| Mr. Expert |
€10-€30 |
European-based service |
</tbody>
</table>
Convenience and Accessibility
The most obvious benefit is the convenience of obtaining an expert opinion without leaving your home. This is particularly valuable for:
- People in rural areas far from qualified appraisers
- Those with mobility issues or transportation limitations
- Large or fragile items that would be difficult to transport
- Preliminary assessments before deciding on more extensive valuation
Cost-Effectiveness
Online appraisals typically cost significantly less than in-person professional valuations, which can run $200-$400 per hour. Most online services charge a flat fee ranging from $19-$69 per item, making them more accessible for multiple items or preliminary assessments.
Quick Turnaround Time
While traditional appraisals might take weeks to schedule and complete, online valuations typically deliver results within 24-48 hours. This rapid response is particularly valuable when making time-sensitive decisions about selling, insuring, or donating items.
Expert Access
Many online platforms employ experts who previously worked with prestigious auction houses and museums. This gives you access to specialized knowledge that might be unavailable locally. According to Consumer Reports, several websites offer legitimate valuations by professional appraisers with expertise in diverse areas from antique furniture to political memorabilia.
Documentation
Online appraisal reports are typically delivered as digital documents, making them easy to store, share with insurance companies, or forward to potential buyers. This organized documentation can be valuable for estate planning and record-keeping purposes.
Is Your Item Ready for Online Appraisal?
Check all applicable items to determine if your antique is properly prepared for digital valuation
Inability to Physically Examine Items
The most significant limitation is that appraisers cannot physically handle the items. This presents several challenges:
-
Authentication Challenges: Without physical examination, it can be difficult to definitively authenticate certain items. Materials, weight, and subtle details may not be fully conveyed through photographs.
-
Condition Assessment Limitations: Damage, repairs, or restorations might be difficult to identify or evaluate accurately through photos alone.
-
Detail Limitations: Small marks, signatures, or other identifying features might be missed if not specifically photographed.
Valuation Precision
Online appraisals typically provide value ranges rather than precise figures. According to Veranda’s article on finding antique values, digital valuations should be considered estimates rather than definitive appraisals, particularly for high-value items.
Legitimacy Concerns
As noted in the Consumer Reports article cited in the research, while many online valuations are legitimate, they provide valuations rather than authentications. This distinction is important for insurance, tax, or legal purposes.
Not Always Suitable for Official Purposes
For certain situations, online appraisals may not be sufficient:
- IRS tax deductions over $5,000
- Legal disputes or divorce settlements
- High-value insurance claims
- Museum donations requiring provenance verification
In these cases, a certified in-person appraisal from an accredited professional might be necessary.
Evolution of Antique Appraisal Methods
-
Pre-2000
Traditional In-Person Appraisals
Before digital transformation, all legitimate appraisals required physical inspection by experts, often requiring travel to specialized appraisers or waiting for traveling appraisal events.
-
2000-2010
Early Online Forums
Collector forums and early websites began offering informal "what's it worth" discussions, though these lacked the structure and expertise of professional appraisals.
-
2010-2015
First Professional Online Services
The first dedicated online appraisal services emerged, employing actual experts and establishing standardized processes for digital valuations.
-
2015-2020
Mainstream Adoption
Major auction houses and established appraisers began offering online services, legitimizing the practice and improving methodology.
-
2020-Present
AI-Enhanced Digital Appraisals
Emerging technologies including AI image recognition are beginning to supplement human expertise, improving accuracy of online appraisals and expanding their capabilities.
Take High-Quality, Detailed Photographs
The quality of your photos directly impacts the accuracy of your appraisal:
- Use good lighting – natural daylight is ideal
- Take photos from multiple angles (front, back, sides, top, bottom)
- Include close-ups of signatures, marks, stamps, or labels
- Capture any damage, repairs, or notable features
- Include a ruler or coin for scale when appropriate
- Ensure images are in focus and high resolution
The more context you can provide, the better:
- Exact measurements and dimensions
- Known history or provenance
- Previous owners or inheritance information
- Any documentation or certificates of authenticity
- Age or period information (if known)
- Material composition
- Previous restoration or repair work
- Purchase information (if available)
Choose the Right Service for Your Item
Different platforms specialize in different categories:
- Heritage Auctions excels with collectibles and fine art
- Mearto has particular strength with antique furniture and decorative arts
- ValueMyStuff covers the broadest range of categories
- Christie’s is best for high-value fine art and luxury items
Consider Multiple Opinions
For valuable or unusual items, consider getting appraisals from multiple services. This can provide a more accurate value range and highlight any disagreements that might warrant further investigation.
Be Upfront About Your Purpose
Let the appraiser know why you’re seeking a valuation:
- For insurance purposes
- To sell the item
- For estate planning
- For tax purposes
- Personal curiosity
This helps them tailor their evaluation to your specific needs.
High-Value Items
For items potentially worth over $10,000, the investment in an in-person appraisal is typically justified. The greater precision and authentication capabilities may significantly impact your selling or insurance decisions.
Authentication Concerns
If you specifically need to verify authenticity rather than just estimate value, in-person examination is preferable. This is particularly important for items frequently counterfeited, such as certain fine art, luxury watches, or rare collectibles.
Legal Requirements
For certain legal purposes, online appraisals may not meet required standards:
- IRS requirements for charitable donations exceeding $5,000
- Court-ordered valuations for estate distribution or divorce proceedings
- Insurance claims for significant losses
Complex or Unusual Items
Some items require physical examination to properly evaluate:
- Mechanical items where functioning affects value
- Items where texture, weight, or sound are important factors
- Objects with potentially valuable components not visible in photos
- Extremely rare items with few comparable sales
Local Market Considerations
If your item has particular regional significance, a local appraiser may have better insight into its value in your specific market than an online service with a national or international perspective.
Common Questions About Online Antique Appraisers
Are online antique appraisals legitimate?
Yes, many online appraisals are legitimate, particularly from established services that employ qualified experts. As noted by Consumer Reports, several websites offer valuations by professional appraisers with expertise in diverse collecting areas.
However, it’s important to understand that online appraisals typically provide valuations rather than authentications. For certain purposes requiring legal standing (such as high-value insurance claims or tax deductions), an in-person appraisal from a certified appraiser may be necessary.
Stick with reputable services like Heritage Auctions, ValueMyStuff, Mearto, or those affiliated with major auction houses for the most reliable results.
How do I get antiques valued online?
The process typically involves these steps:
- Select a reputable online appraisal service appropriate for your item category
- Take clear, detailed photographs from multiple angles
- Measure your item and document any marks, signatures, or distinguishing features
- Complete the service’s submission form with all relevant information about history, condition, and provenance
- Pay the applicable fee (typically $19-$69 per item)
- Receive your valuation report within the specified timeframe (usually 24-48 hours)
Popular options include WorthPoint for their extensive pricing database, Mearto for certified appraisers, and ValueMyStuff for their auction house expertise.
How do I find out if something is antique worth money?
To determine if your antique has significant value:
- Look for maker’s marks, signatures, or labels that identify the creator
- Research the item’s age (generally, items over 100 years old are considered true antiques)
- Assess condition, as this dramatically affects value
- Check for rarity by researching similar items
- Submit photos to an online appraisal service like Heritage Auctions, which offers complimentary auction assessments
- Consult local experts who may have regional market knowledge
- Use online resources like auction archives to find comparable sales
As mentioned in Veranda’s article on finding antique values, exploring auction records can provide valuable insights into an item’s potential worth.
Is there an app to look up antiques?
Yes, several apps can help identify and value antiques:
-
Antique ID - As mentioned in the research, this app helps users discover the stories behind items they find
-
WorthPoint - Offers a vast database of past auction sales and values
-
Google Lens - While not specifically for antiques, this visual search tool can help identify similar items
-
Mearto - Their app connects you directly with appraisers
-
JustCollecting - Specializes in collectibles valuation
While these apps can provide helpful information, they typically work best for preliminary research. For valuable items, following up with a professional appraisal service is recommended for more accurate valuation.
What are the best free online antique appraisal options?
While truly free comprehensive appraisals are limited, several options provide preliminary valuations at no cost:
-
Heritage Auctions - Offers free auction assessments for items being considered for their auctions
-
Christie’s - Provides complimentary auction estimates through their online submission form
-
Auction House Websites - Many auction houses offer free preliminary assessments in hopes of securing items for sale
-
Collector Forums - While not professional appraisals, knowledgeable collectors often provide helpful insights on specialty forums
-
WorthPoint Free Trial - Offers limited access to their vast price database
Keep in mind that free services typically provide less detailed information and are often designed as a preliminary step toward potential consignment or paid services.
Auction Archives and Price Guides
Many auction houses maintain searchable archives of past sales:
- LiveAuctioneers - Extensive archive of past auction results
- Worthpoint - Subscription-based service with millions of verified prices
- Specialty price guides for specific collectibles categories
Antique Shows and Appraisal Events
Look for opportunities to get in-person appraisals at events:
- Antiques Roadshow tours
- Local antique shows with appraiser booths
- Museum-sponsored appraisal days
- Auction house appraisal events
Collector Communities
Specialized forums and social media groups can provide initial insights:
- Facebook groups dedicated to specific collectibles
- Reddit communities like r/Antiques or r/WhatsThisWorth
- Specialized collector forums for niche categories
Local Resources
Don’t overlook expertise in your own community:
- Antique dealers and shops
- Local auction houses
- Museum curators
- University art or history departments
Mobile Apps
As mentioned in the research, apps like Antique ID can help with preliminary identification before seeking professional appraisal.
External Resources for Antique Appraisals
tool
Heritage Auctions Free Appraisals
Submit photos and information about your collectibles for a free evaluation from Heritage Auctions' specialists, who will assess auction potential and estimated values.
tool
ValueMyStuff Online Appraisal Service
Expert appraisals within 24-48 hours starting from $28, with over 60 former Sotheby's and Christie's experts covering more than 40 collecting categories.
tool
Mearto Antique Appraisals
Specialized in antiques and fine art, Mearto provides online appraisals from qualified experts within 24-48 hours, with particular expertise in antique furniture and decorative arts.
article
Consumer Reports: Antique Appraisals Guide
Comprehensive guide from Consumer Reports on how to get accurate appraisals for your valuables, including insights on the legitimacy of online valuation services.
article
Veranda: How to Find the Value of Antiques
Expert advice from Veranda magazine on determining antique values, including tips from professional appraisers and auction specialists.
tool
Christie's Auction Estimates Service
Submit your fine art, antiques, jewelry, or collectibles to Christie's specialists for a complimentary auction estimate through their simple three-step process.
tool
Dr. Lori's Online Appraisal Service
Celebrity appraiser Dr. Lori offers detailed online appraisals that include actual sales records showing where similar objects have sold and for what prices.
tool
Prestige Estate Services Online Appraisals
Quick photo evaluation service that provides appraisal results within 72 hours, ideal for inherited items or estate valuations.
Conclusion: Is an Online Antique Appraiser Right for You?
Online antique appraisal services offer a valuable middle ground between informal research and expensive in-person professional appraisals. They provide accessibility, affordability, and convenience that makes expert opinions available to more people than ever before.
However, they’re not the perfect solution for every situation. For items of significant value, those needing authentication, or appraisals requiring legal standing, traditional in-person appraisals remain the gold standard.
Consider your specific needs, the nature of your item, and your budget when deciding between online and in-person services. For many collectors and inheritors, online appraisals provide an excellent starting point, offering professional insights at an accessible price point.
Whatever approach you choose, ensuring you have accurate information about your antiques and collectibles empowers you to make informed decisions about preservation, insurance, and potential sales—protecting both your treasures and their stories for generations to come.
