Towle Old Master Sterling Silver Value Guide: Pricing, Authentication & Worth

Introduction to Towle Old Master Sterling Silver

Towle Old Master sterling silver flatware is one of the most recognizable and enduring patterns in American silverware. Created by master silversmith Harold E. Nock in the early 1940s, the pattern features refined lines and restrained Victorian-inspired decoration that has appealed to collectors and silver enthusiasts for generations.

The company’s reputation for extraordinary quality and beautiful designs has made Towle sterling silver pieces highly collectible. The Old Master pattern, introduced in the early 1940s, quickly became one of the company’s signature designs and has remained in production for decades, making it both historically significant and readily available to collectors.

William Moulton II establishes himself as the first silversmith in Newbury, Massachusetts.

The company is formally renamed Towle & Son, establishing the brand name known today.

Harold E. Nock designs the Old Master pattern, styled in the Old Victorian tradition.

Towle joins Syratech Corporation along with other silver brands.

Towle continues as a prominent silver brand under Lifetime Brands ownership.

According to recent appraisals and market listings, Towle Old Master sterling flatware maintains strong value relative to other silver patterns. Expert appraisals from JustAnswer indicate that a standard set of Towle Old Master sterling flatware is worth approximately $1,200-$1,500, while larger and more complete sets can reach values of $6,000-$6,500.

For complete sets, the value increases significantly with the number of place settings and additional serving pieces:

• 4-Piece Setting: $760-$800
• 5-Piece Setting: $925-$1,000
• 12-Place Setting: $1,600-$3,000 (varies with condition and serving pieces)
• Complete Service for 12 with Serving Pieces: $6,000-$6,500

Completeness of Set

The number of place settings and variety of serving pieces significantly impact value. A complete service for 8 or 12 with numerous serving pieces will command a premium price compared to individual pieces or partial sets.

Condition

Sterling silver pieces in excellent condition with minimal wear, no repairs, and no damage will be worth substantially more than those with issues. Signs of heavy use, monogramming, deep scratches, or dents can reduce value by 20-50%.

Rarity of Pieces

Some Towle Old Master pieces were produced in limited quantities or only during certain periods. Rare serving pieces like asparagus servers, fish slices, or specialty cocktail forks typically command higher prices than standard pieces.

Provenance

Documented history of ownership, especially if connected to notable individuals or families, can increase value. Original packaging, certificates of authenticity, and documentation can also positively impact worth.

Hallmarks and Maker’s Marks

Authentic Towle Old Master sterling silver pieces feature distinct hallmarks that help with identification:

1. The Towle name in a stylized format
2. The word “STERLING” indicating 92.5% silver content
3. Pattern identification mark (may not be present on all pieces)
4. Sometimes a date mark or year code

Design Characteristics

The Old Master pattern has distinct design elements:

• Styled in the Old Victorian tradition
• Refined lines with restrained decoration
• Elegant curved handles with subtle ornamental details at the end
• Designed by silversmith Harold E. Nock
• Balanced weight and substantial feel in hand

Common Reproductions to Avoid

Several silver-plated and stainless steel reproductions of the Old Master pattern exist. Key differences include:

• Weight (sterling is heavier than silver-plate or stainless)
• Hallmarks (reproductions lack proper sterling silver markings)
• Detail sharpness (authentic pieces have crisper, more defined details)
• Patina (genuine sterling develops a distinctive tarnish over time)

Best Places to Sell

1. Auction Houses: For complete sets or rare pieces, reputable auction houses like Cottone Auctions or specialized silver auctions can yield good returns.

2. Online Marketplaces: eBay and other online platforms offer wide exposure but require careful shipping considerations. Recent eBay listings for Towle Old Master have shown strong collector interest.

3. Sterling Silver Dealers: Specialty dealers like Silver Superstore, Sterling Collectables, or local antique silver dealers may purchase complete sets.

4. Consignment Shops: Higher-end consignment stores in affluent areas often accept quality sterling silver on consignment.

5. Silver Refiners: As a last resort, sterling can be sold for its metal value, though this typically yields only 20-30% of the retail value of intact flatware.

Price Expectations When Selling

Sellers should realistically expect to receive 50-70% of the current retail value when selling to dealers or through auction houses. Direct sales to collectors can yield higher returns but may take longer to complete.

• Retail Price Recovery: 50-70% when selling complete sets to dealers
• Individual Piece Value: 40-60% of retail when selling separate pieces
• Silver Melt Value: approximately 20-30% of the retail flatware value
• Auction Returns: 60-80% of retail value for quality sets (minus seller fees)

Starting a Collection

1. Begin with Essential Pieces: Focus on acquiring basic place setting pieces first (dinner forks, salad forks, teaspoons, tablespoons).

2. Condition Priority: Choose pieces in excellent condition, even if it means purchasing fewer items initially.

3. Matching Patterns: Ensure all pieces feature identical pattern details, as subtle variations existed over the production years.

4. Storage Solutions: Invest in appropriate anti-tarnish storage to maintain condition and value.

Investment Considerations

Towle Old Master sterling silver has maintained consistent value over time, making it both a functional household asset and a potential investment. Key investment considerations include:

• Complete sets hold value better than individual pieces
• Serving pieces typically appreciate faster than standard flatware
• Excellent condition pieces command premium prices
• Original packaging adds significant value for collectors

Cleaning and Polishing

1. Gentle Cleaning: Wash pieces by hand using mild dish soap and warm water. Avoid dishwashers.

2. Appropriate Polish: Use quality silver polish products specifically designed for sterling silver.

3. Polishing Technique: Polish with a soft cotton cloth using straight, non-circular motions following the pattern lines.

4. Frequency: Clean after use, but limit polishing to 1-2 times per year to prevent excessive wear.

Storage Recommendations

1. Anti-tarnish Storage: Use specially designed anti-tarnish cloth, bags, or storage chests.

2. Avoid Contact: Prevent pieces from touching by using cloth dividers or individual wrapping.

3. Climate Control: Store in a stable environment with moderate humidity and temperature.

4. Original Chests: If available, original Towle storage chests provide ideal protection and add value.

Yes, Towle is considered one of America's oldest and most respected silver brands. Established in 1690 in Massachusetts, Towle Silversmiths has maintained a reputation for exceptional quality and craftsmanship for over three centuries. Their sterling silver products, including the Old Master pattern, are highly regarded by collectors and silver enthusiasts for their beauty, durability, and historical significance.

The value of a Towle Old Master sterling silver flatware set varies based on size and condition. According to expert appraisals, a standard set is typically worth between $1,200-$1,500, while larger, complete sets with serving pieces can reach $6,000-$6,500. Individual 5-piece place settings retail for approximately $925-$1,000, and 4-piece settings for $760-$800. Rare or exceptional sets in original packaging can command even higher prices.

Towle sterling silver was historically manufactured in Newburyport, Massachusetts, where William Moulton II established the company that would become Towle Silversmiths in 1690. The company maintained its American production through most of its history. In more recent decades, following corporate acquisitions and restructuring, production methods and locations have changed, but the brand's American heritage remains a significant part of its identity and appeal.

Authentic Towle Old Master sterling silver can be identified by several key features:

- The Towle hallmark clearly stamped on each piece
- The word "STERLING" indicating 92.5% silver content
- The distinctive Old Victorian-inspired design with refined lines
- Proper weight (sterling silver is heavier than silver-plate alternatives)
- Quality craftsmanship with crisp, well-defined pattern details
- A balanced, substantial feel when held

Be wary of pieces without proper hallmarks or those that feel unusually light, as these may be reproductions or silver-plated alternatives.

The best selling method depends on your priorities:

1. For maximum value: Direct sales to collectors through platforms like eBay or specialized forums
2. For convenience: Reputable silver dealers or consignment shops
3. For complete sets: Auction houses specializing in silver or antiques
4. For damaged pieces: Silver refiners who will pay for the metal content

Complete sets generally command better prices than individual pieces. Having original packaging, documentation, or provenance information can significantly increase selling value.

The Towle Old Master pattern was designed by master silversmith Harold E. Nock and introduced in the early 1940s. Its Old Victorian-inspired styling with refined lines and restrained decoration quickly made it popular among consumers seeking elegant yet durable sterling silver flatware. The pattern has remained in production for decades, making it both historically significant and relatively available to collectors compared to some discontinued patterns.

Professional appraisal is recommended in several situations:

1. For insurance purposes, especially for complete sets
2. Before selling valuable or extensive collections
3. For estate planning and distribution
4. When determining the authenticity of pieces with uncertain provenance

Professional appraisers can provide detailed documentation of your silver's value, condition, and authenticity, which can be valuable for insurance, sales, or estate purposes. The cost of appraisal is typically worthwhile for collections valued over $1,000.

Yes, monogramming typically reduces the value of Towle Old Master silver by 15-30%, depending on several factors:

1. Size and prominence of the monogram
2. Aesthetic quality of the engraving
3. Location on the piece
4. Historical significance of the monogram

Subtle, attractive monograms have less negative impact than large or poorly executed ones. In rare cases, monograms linked to historical figures or prominent families can actually increase value. Professional removal of monograms is not recommended as it typically causes more damage than the monogram itself.

As with many collectibles, the investment value of Towle Old Master sterling silver depends largely on acquisition price, condition, and market timing. However, several factors make this pattern a relatively stable store of value:

1. Enduring Design: The classic, restrained Old Victorian styling has remained fashionable for generations.

2. Reputable Manufacturer: Towle’s long history and reputation for quality support long-term value.

3. Intrinsic Metal Value: Unlike many collectibles, sterling silver has inherent precious metal value.

4. Functional Art: Unlike purely decorative collectibles, sterling flatware serves a practical purpose while being displayed.

For those considering Towle Old Master as an investment, focusing on complete sets in excellent condition with serving pieces will likely yield the best long-term value appreciation. While not likely to produce spectacular returns, quality sterling silver has historically maintained purchasing power over time while providing both aesthetic and functional benefits to its owners.

Comprehensive catalog of available Towle Old Master pieces with current retail pricing and pattern information.

Detailed pattern information and purchasing options for collectors seeking specific Towle Old Master pieces.

Wikipedia article providing historical background on Towle Silversmiths company from its founding to modern day.

Professional appraisal examples and valuation information from certified appraisers for Towle Old Master collections.

Current retail offerings with detailed product descriptions and pricing for Towle Old Master pieces.

Current auctions and sales listings for Towle Old Master pieces, providing real-time market value indicators.

Auction results and upcoming listings for Towle silver pieces including Old Master pattern items.

General information about sterling silver flatware valuation principles and market considerations.