![Auction comp thumbnail for Law.- Regicides.- [Finch (Heneage, Earl of Nottingham)] An exact and most impartial accompt of the indictment, arraignment, trial, and judgment (according to law) of twenty nine regicides, Printed for ⦠(Forum Auctions - UK, Lot 28)](https://assets.appraisily.com/articles/who-according-to-irs-is-a-qualified-appraiser/auctions/auction-forum-auctions-uk-28.jpg)
If you’re donating art, antiques, collectibles, or other noncash property and planning to claim a charitable deduction, the IRS uses a strict definition of a qualified appraiser. This isn’t a marketing label—it’s a compliance standard tied to whether your deduction is allowed.
This guide explains (in plain English) who the IRS considers qualified, what disqualifies an otherwise skilled expert, what a qualified appraisal must include, and how to vet the appraiser and report before you sign Form 8283.
Quick answer: what the IRS is looking for
For donation-related filings, the IRS expects an appraiser who is competent for your property type, regularly paid for appraisals, independent of the transaction, and able to deliver (and sign) a report that meets IRS “qualified appraisal” content and timing rules.
- Competence: education + at least two years of experience appraising the type of property.
- Professional practice: routinely performs appraisals for compensation (not just occasional opinions).
- Independence: no conflicts and no fees tied to value or deduction outcome.
- Documentation: a signed report with method + market evidence, and signatures where required (including Form 8283 when applicable).
Qualified appraiser vs qualified appraisal (don’t confuse these)
People often focus on the person, but compliance is a two-part test: the appraiser must meet IRS requirements, and the appraisal report must also meet IRS requirements. You need both.
| Requirement | What to verify | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Qualified appraiser | Property-type education/experience, compensated practice, independence, no disqualifiers. | An otherwise solid value conclusion can be rejected if the signer isn’t “qualified.” |
| Qualified appraisal | Correct timing window, signed report, required descriptions, methods, comps/market evidence, and declarations. | Even a qualified appraiser can produce a non-qualifying report if required elements are missing. |
| Substantiation | Form 8283 completion/signatures and (for high-value cases) attaching the appraisal or meeting additional IRS documentation rules. | Missing attachments or signatures can put the entire deduction at risk. |
Who is not qualified (common disqualifiers & red flags)
A respected curator, dealer, or collector can have real expertise and still be disqualified for IRS purposes due to conflicts. Use this as a screening list.
| Red flag | Why the IRS may object | Safer alternative |
|---|---|---|
| The seller/dealer who sold you the item (or an employee/related party) | Not independent; the IRS treats parties to the acquisition as conflicted. | Use a third-party appraiser with no financial interest in the outcome. |
| The donee charity (or someone employed by the charity) | Conflicts of interest with the donation. | Hire an external appraiser; ask the charity for process guidance only. |
| Fee depends on value (“percentage of appraised value”) | Contingent fees undermine independence. | Use hourly or flat-fee pricing with a clear scope of work. |
| “Generalist” claiming to appraise everything | Competence must match the property type being appraised. | Match specialty to category (e.g., prints, bronzes, silver, rare books). |
Form 8283 thresholds (fast cheat sheet)
Donation substantiation depends on value thresholds. The table below is a practical starting point, but confirm current instructions for your tax year and property type.
| Situation | Common IRS requirement | What to plan for |
|---|---|---|
| Noncash donation > $5,000 | Qualified appraisal + Form 8283 (Section B) | Hire the right specialist early; collect photos and documentation. |
| Single item (art) ≥ $20,000 | Additional substantiation (often appraisal attachment) | Expect higher scrutiny; use a defensible method + comps. |
| Donations ≥ $500,000 (certain property) | Attach qualified appraisal to return | Keep full workfile; assume review is possible. |
Checklist: confirming an IRS-qualified appraiser
Use this decision tree when you interview an appraiser. It helps you verify both qualifications and independence.
Practical checklist (questions to ask)
- Category match: “How many appraisals have you done for this category in the last 12 months?”
- Credentials: “What coursework/designations support this specialty?”
- Independence: “Do you buy/sell in this category?” “Any ties to the charity?”
- Fees: “Is your fee hourly/flat?” (Avoid value-contingent fees.)
- Report readiness: “Will your report include comps and meet IRS qualified appraisal elements?”
- Signing: “Will you sign the appraiser declaration and Form 8283 where required?”
What a qualified appraisal report should include (audit-ready)
A qualified appraisal typically reads like a defensible valuation memo: it describes the object in a way another expert could identify it, explains the market and method used, and supports the conclusion with evidence.
Practical tip: Ask for a short sample report outline (with client data removed). You’re checking structure and evidence, not “pretty PDF” design.
- Identification: maker/artist attribution, materials, dimensions, inscriptions/marks, edition details.
- Condition & authenticity notes: restoration, damage, replacements, provenance, and any uncertainty disclosures.
- Valuation approach: what market is relevant, why that market, and which methods were used.
- Comparable sales (“comps”): similar items, with differences adjusted and explained.
- Effective date + intended use: donation FMV vs insurance replacement value are not the same.
Example comps: how FMV evidence looks in practice
Below are three real auction results (internal DB) to show the type of evidence a qualified appraisal often cites. Your appraiser should use comps that match your category and explain why each comp is comparable.
| Comp | Auction details | Realized price |
|---|---|---|
| Illustrated book (Audebert, primates) | Sotheby’s · Lot 3 · 2023-11-28 | £15,240 hammer |
| Modern art (Zdenek Sykora) | Koller Auctions · Lot 3470 · 2021-12-02 | CHF 400,000 hammer |
| Painting (Marcel Dyf) | Sotheby’s · Lot 211 · 2007-02-15 | $15,600 hammer |
Comp images (for context)
Photo pack: what to photograph for the appraiser
Even the best appraiser can’t defend FMV without good identification and condition evidence. Use the gallery below as a quick checklist of the kinds of details that typically matter in art and antiques appraisal work.
Inspection cues (gallery)
Short FAQ
Does USPAP compliance automatically make an appraiser “qualified” for the IRS? Not automatically. USPAP is a quality baseline, but the IRS definition also focuses on property-type competence, independence, compensated practice, and meeting the qualified appraisal content/timing requirements.
Can a dealer write the appraisal? Dealers often know the market, but they may be conflicted—especially if they sold the piece, want to buy it, or charge contingent fees. A qualified appraisal should be independent.
Do I need comps in the report? In most categories, market evidence (including comps) is a core way to support FMV. The report should explain why the comps are comparable and how differences were handled.
Search variations collectors ask
Readers often Google:
- who is considered a qualified appraiser for IRS Form 8283
- IRS qualified appraiser requirements for art donation over 5000
- what disqualifies an appraiser for charitable contribution appraisal
- does a USPAP appraiser count as IRS qualified appraiser
- can a dealer appraise an item for tax donation purposes
- what must a qualified appraisal include for IRS donation
- how to vet a qualified appraiser for antiques donation
- Form 8283 appraisal date within 60 days rule explained
Each question is addressed in the guide above—use it as a pre-signing checklist.
This article is educational and focuses on charitable-contribution appraisal standards. For tax decisions, consult your tax advisor and ensure your appraiser’s qualifications and report match the latest IRS rules for your filing year.
